The legendary Section 28 is finally gone. BCN asked Scottish bisexuals – who have been free of it for some time – about life after “the clause”.
Going… Going…
Scotland, 2000AD. The 15 to 20% of the general population who were, on a daily basis, directly affected by this evil and bigoted legislation had been promised its removal by the new devolved administration and they could breathe a collective sigh of relief now that it was finally being removed.
Or could they….
In the same way that controlled hysteria had been whipped up previously about Communism in the 50s, the Glasgow based Daily Record set about a campaign to retain this hated piece of legislation without looking deeply at the people the act was designed to help to protect.
In an attempt to balance things out, its sister paper, Sunday Mail, took the opposite viewpoint, however one days viewpoint could do nothing to the six previous days venom spewed by the Record. Aided and abetted by bus operator, the millionaire Brian Souter to a substantial financial assistance, and specific religious denominations with their slanted perspectives on human life practices and emotion, the hate campaign trundled on adopting crusade-like overtones.
Similar acts of defiance took ultra-serious, and even hilarious, overtones. I can remember a series of organized campaigns of information
led by human and gay rights activists over the duration of the campaign. These would be countered by the free ‘family’ days funded by all the parties interested in suppressing free speech and the basic human right to live your own life.
Other forms of civil defiance took the form of depleting the fund for the freepost address, ranging from sending fridges and garden gates, to hundreds of blank envelopes. I personally plead guilty to in excess of 500 envelopes myself, resulting in writers cramp for days and a ruined sex life. The rumours of me stalking cute brunette staff in a certain large stationers, are not true…..
One particular truly gutsy and amazing venture involved a gaudy cosmetic job on a bus belonging to a certain bus group owner, planned with the devoted skill of a military campaign. How we all applauded, and wet our underwear, at that one, I remember that day and its representation in another Glasgow paper. Score one to the militant sisterhood. As a sad aside, hate assaults would soar over this period, thugs now being able to justify their behaviour as keeping the streets clean of any undesirables as they were doing it for the 80% of ‘normal’ people, that oppressive moral majority.
But despite the hysteria created, despite the hate that was being regularly whipped up at every opportunity, despite staunch believers leaving in droves, despite the campaign of tragic misinformation and sheer hate spread by these religions, this newspaper and a propaganda website manufactured by the ‘Keep the clause’ campaign….. the clause was finally repealed by our forward thinking government.
Over this period of uncertainty, I frequently asked myself what would have happened if a piece of legislation had been targeted against a particular religious group, or a gender, or perhaps those with any kind of disability? Those same protestors who would be quick to deny us those basic freedoms, would have been the first to create merry hell. Indeed, there is a variety of existing legislation in place to protect the individual at the workplace from such nonsense or to protect ones own personal liberties.
Why are gay and bisexual people targeted? It’s easy, it’s not as obvious. It’s easy to preach civil liberties when only 40 years before, the gay lifestyle was a criminal offense. Equality is needed, but it needs to be true equality. Do you see gangs of gay neds going round the city ‘straight-bashing’? No, you don’t. We are not above such things, but we don’t do it, but we do have the right to get angry like everyone else. We need to be the ones who set the record straight.
Perhaps we need to air our clean laundry in public, rather than constantly air our dirty laundry, tressing all the influences the gay and bisexual communities have to offer, indeed, have already offered. But, will it ever be enough?
In the film “X Men” from the same year, Professor Charles Xavier says: “Mankind isn’t evil, simply misinformed”, so we have to be the ones to inform. The genre cult comic is a lesson in how people born different are treated by the majority. The villainous Magneto is played with a sympathetic sinister side by the great Ian McKellen, no stranger to the worlds bigotries, being gay himself. The 2003 sequel, reunites many of the same cast, and it has a particular scene where one young mutant, Bobby Drake aka Iceman, has to ‘out’ himself and his companions, as one of those having a mutant ability, during a conversation about ‘the mutant problem’. His mother’s response said with the straightest face, which is one who many gay or bisexual people will have heard or at least a variation of it, “Have you ever tried, not being a mutant?”
In writing this, I did a lot of thinking back over those three and a half years, it’s been an interesting time. Are things different? Yes. Are they more relaxed for the majority? Again, I would need to say, for the majority at least, the answer is yes. I always hope that one day everyone will be what they can be, live the way they want to live, and not live in fear of physical, verbal or emotional assault, not just here but worldwide. But this basic human freedom to live a long and fruitful life, is a luxury that is not enjoyed worldwide, this is all too obvious from chatting to folks like myself on the internet. Human rights are trodden on in the name of ‘the greater good’, the will of the people, or that old chestnut, the will of a tribal god image. Every day I hope this changes.
There is nothing glaringly different from me and the average guy in the street. I don’t have a blue face and the ability to teleport, nor can I read thoughts, nor can I cause extremes of temperature. I do bleed red, I do breathe oxygen, I do have the balls to get up and let rip at a karaoke, I do like Vodka and Bacardi and cider, I am proud to be bisexual. While before, I would looked at that as a disability, but no more – I now see that as an enhancement to what I am. I am not a Mutant, I am not a freak of nature, but I do like EastEnders and Kat Slater (and please don’t tell everyone, but I am getting to really like River City too).
I live in constant hope that we eventually get our enlightened 21st century!
Gerry
Bisexuals Fighting Section 28 in Scotland
I arrived in Scotland from New Zealand in March 1997, and soon after woke up to headlines saying “No Tory Seats in Scotland”. So, I never had a lot of experience with living as a bisexual in Tory Britain. Then came the referendum and devolution – I stayed up all night to watch the results. My mother, a Scot, said my grandmother would be dancing in her grave with joy. Moving to Glasgow in early 1999 to work at the Glasgow School of Art plonked me down in the middle of one of the liveliest gay scenes in the UK. I got a room sharing with a famous lesbian who asked me not to tell anyone I was bisexual, for her separatist friends would be very angry with her. We had a lot of good conversations during my time there, but it’s hard to imagine now that I just swallowed that (and the “no men” rule), in order to have a home.
I fell madly in love with an unavailable lesbian and, smarting from that rejection, drove across the country to check out this thing called “BiCon ‘99” in Edinburgh. I hadn’t registered and didn’t have anywhere to sleep, so I crashed the first night at a (straight) friend’s place. After she found out where I’d been she never spoke to me again. The second night, I pulled, so I had somewhere to sleep, plus a positive experience of BiCon that has never left me. I put up a notice asking for other Glasgow bisexuals to help form a Glasgow bisexual group.
Our first meeting was in October 1999. We made a splash in Glasgow straight away, getting along to the Glasgow Gay and Lesbian Centre’s board meetings to ask them to include bisexuals and change their name. While we were fighting that good fight, and suffering vehement attacks from some members of the gay community (although we had great support too!), Scotland began the process of repealing Section 28. Souter got his homophobe bus into gear, and the level of open homophobia in my workplace increased markedly. My phone calls asking for support from the Lesbian & Gay section of UNISON were distressing- they refused to help a bisexual. And a weekly council of war was held at the GGLC and in Edinburgh. For once the local gay and lesbian activists (including UNISON) were happy to see us- suddenly we were all in it together, and we stood on the stall in Sauchiehall Street handing out postcards for people to send to their MSPs. A scary prospect, but I treasure the memory of the number of ordinary Scots who signed postcards and offered us their support with Glasgow-style scathing diatribes on Souter and his ilk.
I remember the triumphant drinking session afterwards, where one gay activist told the joke “What’s the difference between a gay man and a straight man? About 6 ½ pints”. To which I replied “Same distance as between a gay man and a bisexual man then. In my experience”. There was a collective intake of breath around the table, but for once they couldn’t run me out of town, because I’d just stood and faced the mob with them. Sweet.
Meantime, a local community radio show called DiverseCity, run by the humanist group who provided space for Bi Glasgow’s meetings, asked us if we wanted one of their slots to do a show on whatever we liked. Neil and I said yes, and we decided that, rather than focusing on general bi issues, we would do something special for the Section 28 campaign.
The show was on a local Asian station, and at that time, Souter’s campaign had solved the crusades by uniting local Muslim and Catholic groups against gays. So we decided to do a show on Asian and Muslim LGB issues. We tried to find interviewees, but noone living in Scotland felt safe enough to go on air. We ended up with contributors from Al-Fatiha UK and a London Asian gay men’s health organisation, plus a gay head teacher from Scotland. The station itself was run by very young local Muslims. They welcomed us, but both sides were wary. The humanist guy who hosted for us looked increasingly nervous as the show progressed. Then the calls started to come in, one after another from the local Muslim community. I only ever heard our friend’s side of those calls and he aquitted himself admirably, staying calm and continually affirming that the show’s job was to provide a voice for all those in society who didn’t have a voice elsewhere. The sweat stains on his shirt spread quickly. As a straight guy who’d probably never fended off homophobia anywhere before, he really was dropped in it! He was thrilled that one caller eventually and grudgingly took his point about freedom of speech. All I could hope for was that maybe just one lesbian or gay or bisexual young person out there heard the show and that it helped them.
Finally, just as we were entering the final and fiercest phase of our battle to change the name of the GGLC to Glasgow LGBT Centre, and just as Section 28 was repealed, one of our members committed suicide. I remember that final board meeting, two days later, where the vote was being taken. The very same head teacher we had interviewed for the radio show got up and argued that including bisexuals and transgendered people would dilute the gay political message; that we were not part of his community. At the end of my tether, I got up and spoke about our dead friend Robert. I don’t remember what I said but we won the vote that day; Bi Glasgow soon moved its meetings into a room at the Glasgow LGBT Centre. And the whole LGBT community celebrated its success with Section 28. I feel Scotland really started to crystalise as a fledgling democracy through this time, although it was scary getting the train to work past homophobic billboards and newspaper hoardings.
Stories from places like Cyprus and Turkey that some of us heard at the recent ILGA-Europe Conference in Glasgow were a reminder of how lucky we are in Britain, but my memories of the events during the Section 28 campaign in Scotland also remind that we don’t have far to fall, should the balance of power in politics shift. England and Wales are joining us in being Section 28 free – congratulations and well done! But let’s not forget …
Sarah Currier
VoxBiPop
BCN asked on UK bi email groups about your experiences of section 28…
Not a particularly bi angle, but I remember the Glasgow Gay & Lesbian Centre Project (the fundraising and campaigning forerunner to the LGBT Centre) was trying to get a venue for one of its first fundraising events. Glasgow City Council refused to allow the hire of one of its halls, on the grounds that it would be infringing Section 28. Which was clearly laughable, as it wasn’t even connected to education.
I also remember the Section 28 news coverage circa 1988 (Nicholas Witchell sitting on a lesbian, Boy George’s terrible single) provoked quite a bit of chat in school. Most of it was homophobic, but in a strange way I think that it encouraged more awareness of the issues and that there was an organised LGBT community who would stand up for their rights.
David, Glasgow list
A senior teacher taking us for sex education in Nottingham in the mid ’80s
told us clearly that he would answer any of our questions honestly and listen if we had concerns, regardless of the law. I respected him for that and still do.
Grant, East Mids list
17th November 2003 is a truly special day, I am over the moon.
I went to a private school which was boys only. As at most places and for most kids it was the familiar story of homos and gays being the scum of society and the words being used to put people down. I really fancied a lad in my year at school but rather than feeling able to express my feelings I tried to deny my feelings as I was so ashamed of them. I didn’t have anybody I could talk to. Those feelings lay buried for years.
Hopefully nowadays kids can grow up in a more supportive environment in which they feel their is nothing wrong with having same sex sexual attractions. Kids could really do without the pressures I suffered and the feelings of low sense of self-worth that came with it.
Tom, East Mids list
There was a kind of “up side” to the clause: it helped to engage many of us in politics, through direct action and protests, because it’s easiest to get involved when you feel directly affected by the decisions politicians have made.
Jen, Manchester list
