At the very end of February, Lord Lester of Herne Hill brought his Equality Bill before the upper house. In Northern Ireland, where there is already a single Equality Commission, the Government are working actively to introduce a single Equality Bill. Despite talk of joined-up government, there is no sign that they are working in the same way to introduce a single Equality Bill for Great Britain.
Introducing the second reading of the equality bill, Lord Lester said, ‘New Labour’s 1997 election manifesto promised that, if elected to government, they would, “eliminate unjustifiable discrimination wherever it exists”. The Liberal Democrat manifesto contained a commitment to enact a single Equality Act. This Bill seeks to give effect to those commitments”.’
Lester went on to attack the Government for having failed to grasp the opportunity for comprehensive reform in such an over-arching bill, to bring the law on many issues of discrimination up to date in a ‘big bang’ change.
However, the government have published draft regulations to implement the EU race and framework employment directives, with a period for public consultation that was completed at the end of January. They have consulted about proposals to create a single equality commission.
Soon, Labour are expected to lay before Parliament new regulations on sex, sexual orientation, race, religion and belief, and disability. A consultation on draft age discrimination regulations will be delayed until December 2006.
Predictable opposition from the religious benches in the house came from the Lord Bishop of Winchester who accepted that “for many people now, their sexual orientation is explicitly a matter of their choice rather than one that they themselves understand to be intrinsic to their identity.”
He protested at legislation on sexual orientation being extended to religious institutions however. “The Church of England, along with other Churches and faith groups, is accustomed to draw a clear distinction between “orientation… and “behaviour”. We are now being advised that courts and tribunals are unlikely to recognise any clear-cut distinction along those lines in considering claims of discrimination brought under legislation that is pending. The effect will be that actions taken by the Churches to enforce their doctrines and beliefs in relation to sexual conduct will be rendered unlawful.”
A sign of the times was the way this case was being argued as the Bishop continued, “In making these points, I am not challenging the principle that people who understand themselves as homosexual, or transgendered, should have full equality and protection before the law and the fullest freedom from prejudice, homophobic violence and unfair discrimination. However, it is crucial that legislation that properly seeks to ensure that equality should not—in my judgment improperly—encroach on the freedom and the right that religious organisations must have to set and enforce their own conduct rules in relation to those who work for them and represent them”
Labour peer Lord Alli responded that he still found “it amazing that Houses of God should find anti-discrimination legislation a difficult concept and continue to perpetuate a form of righteous discrimination.”
“The principle of creating a level playing field of legislation for different areas of equality is an important one. I believe that no institution or organisation should be exempt from it.”
As with Lord Lester’s proposals for partnership rights last year, it is not anticipated that this bill will be made law, but that it will serve to ‘test the water’ in the Lords and Commons for such changes in future.
