How times change. Once upon a time gay icon Tom Robinson fell in love with a woman and became a pariah – and a regular at Bicon. Now Stephen Daldry (director of Billy Elliott) gets married and everybody’s cool about it.

The Guardian (New wed Daldry in the pink, 23/11/01) euphemistically described Daldry as ‘a confirmed bachelor in every sense in the word’ (perhaps they feared a libel suit a la Jason Donovan?) and the wedding as his ‘conversion to heterosexual married bliss’ (ugh). The article’s throwaway link to September 11 suggests that queer identities aren’t part of the new ‘New World Order’ so beloved of Bush and Blair. (No change there then.)

But it was the comment piece by Charlie Potter (What is it about gay men and marriage? 23/11/01) that really rankled. The standfirst described Daldry as ‘widely assumed to be gay’ – maybe that’s what being a theatre director and making your first film about a male ballet dancer does for your reputation. To Potter’s credit, he does acknowledge the hostility directed at Tom Robinson, but then ruins everything with ‘since homosexuality as a militant issue has waned, the word bisexuality is seen as a slur’ – a very odd take on the history of relations between lesbians/gays and bi’s. He then cites Michael ‘I’m sexual’ Stipe of REM and comedienne Jackie Clune both rejecting the b-word. The latter surpasses herself with ‘I hate the label: it’s naff, it smacks of key-swapping fondue parties’ – this from a woman who has used the songs of Karen Carpenter as part of her act!

Potter sees all this, not as symptoms of biphobia, or even of denial, but more as signs of a growing maturity and depoliticisation of ‘gay’ identity. He implies that the ‘born that way’ arguments are being countered by ‘gay men [who] see their sexuality as a short-term option, forever subject to alteration according to whim, age, or social position.’ Sounds like fun.

What galls me, however, is that this argument makes sense as a form of ‘queer’ identity – yet it only seems to apply to lesbians and gays who’ve ‘paid their dues’. Not to bisexuals (who ought to be given credit for arriving at a similar conclusion a lot sooner), not to polyamorists (since these queer newlyweds are presumed to be monogamous) – and certainly not to heterosexuals who do (or at least could) cross supposedly rigid boundaries and have same-sex partners.

At this point I must confess my own hesitation about naming myself as bi – but this is more because my sexual journey so far has been via SM rather than any history of desire for men or women (see BCN 28). I’d like to think that the dismantling of the ‘You Are Whom You Fuck’ model of sexual identity would create a space in which ‘queer’ desires would either flourish or become normalised. Unfortunately, articles such as Potter’s and comments such as Clune’s suggest that only those with the appropriate history and credentials need apply.

Derrick