Modern scientific inquiry is usually dichotomous, in that it seeks to investigate two things regarded as the opposite of each other. For instance, many medical studies compare a group of patients who have had a treatment with those who have not, and computers make calculations using a binary on/off code. This method is all well and good for some kinds of questions, but only works in a world that depends on right/wrong, self/other, either/or positions. Such dualism extends into the way people describe their experience, into the false divisions between body and mind, them and us, black and white, straight and gay.
However, dualism becomes insufficient when describing the complexity of many people’s experience, and in particular the experience of being ‘both/and’ that is the case for those who identify as bisexual, or of mixed race or multi-heritage. In the same way that medical research into who did or didn’t swallow the pills doesn’t account for what else made the patients get sick or well, such dichotomous inquiry misses out the middle ground of social, cultural and sexual experience. It leaves the greater number of people who inhabit other than the extreme ends of the spectrum completely invisible and unacknowledged.
Such polarisation is essential to the maintenance of oppositional politics and social systems, as they require an ‘other’ in order to protect the position of the ‘self’. The dominant culture binds itself together by despising groups from the other end of the spectrum, and deemed to be different. This process is replicated throughout society on macro and micro levels, even when contradictory. For example it is evident in the white supremacists’ view of blackness, the Christians’ view of Jewishness, the Jews’ view of Islam, and the homosexuals’ view of bisexuality. Indeed for bisexual people, such a process is contrived into the biphobic insult of being a ‘fence-sitter’, someone who can’t or won’t take up their position at one end of the spectrum or the other, therefore deserving contempt.
It is because of this dichotomy that bisexual identity and theory is so radical and challenging, because it refuses to retreat to the ends of the spectrum, and proclaims the existence of the missing middle. Promisingly, the most recent and refreshing western academic thought is moving towards ideas of integration and consensus, as no single discipline can progress without reference to the others. In the east, such ideas of unity have been long since embedded in the culture. Quantum theory is at the cutting edge of all this, in which the constituent parts of the universe are both waves and particles at the same time. Perhaps then, bisexual theory can be at the forefront of philosophical and scientific developments, having always been able to hold a ‘both/and’ position in preference to ‘either/or’.
And maybe a new badge for Jennifer to produce would be ‘bisexuality – a wave and a particle’ or ‘quantum bi’…or maybe I should just shut up and turn my gaze back to my navel…!
Bobbie
