Those of us with a non-standard sexuality are in an ambiguous position with the law today. On the one hand, very little that we do is illegal even under such badged-up laws as the Spanner precedent,and most police officers will recite liberal platitudes about how your private life is your own affair.
On the other hand, there are a great many police – all too often in positions of authority – who believe fiercely,sometimes literally evangelically,that people doing things they don’t like must be breaking the law,and if they can’t find a law that’s being broken they will invent one. They don’t get many convictions, because they are puffing against the wind of social change, but they don’t appearlo mind: probably because they know that between scandal,expense, and all the other hardships they can inflict on someone in the grip of the system, they don’t actually have to get a Guilty verdict to punish their victims.
However, this is not a counsel of despair.
These people are essentially bullies in search of weaklings, and the rule with them is the same as with any bully. If you seem apologetic, afraid or confused, you look like a victim and will be victimised. If you act confident, assertive and as if you know what you are doing, you have a sporting chance that they will back off and look for an easier target.
Many people reading this will have difficulty accepting such a negative view of the police. Butthe first thing to understand, if you are arrested, is that it’s not paranoia if they really are out to get you: and once you are arrested they are out to get you, because if they release you without charge they feel they have failed. Paranoid is the rational way to think.
When I was first arrested I had as much trouble as anyone getting usedto this idea. All the way to the station I felt certain that we would just have a sensible talk, I would explain the mistake and go home. Only when they started putting the contents of my pockets in a bag did I grasp that this was serious, start thinking paranoid, and ask for a solicitor.
This isthe first thing you must do,and don’t let anyone tell you it looks guilty.You don’t know what innocent remarks might betaken out of context and made to look damaging:
the solicitor does. You won’t know what
traps they are setting for you:the solicitor will. Even if you are certain this could never happen to you, it doesn’t hurt to think about who you would call if it did. You don’t haveto memorise a phone number: if you give them a name,they haveto look it up.
From one point of view Iwas lucky.The police were certain that what they were looking for was in my files, and only wanted me banged up to stop me warning my supposed conspirators; so they didn’t try to lead me to talk before I was locked away, or send someone to my cell for a sympathetic man-to-man chat to see if I would incriminate myself. These things are illegal, and there are elaborate rules to stop them happening, but any lawyer will tell you that they happen. I had already resolved to say nothing but I’m not saying anything without a solicitor, but I’m not sure how long I could have held to it: the urge to explain and justify oneself under pressure is very strong.
But from the other point of view,the fact that they weren’t interested in questioning me till they had found what they were after – and that they never found it because it didn’t exist – meant that I spent a day alone in a concrete box four paces by three furnished with a plastic mattress and a stainless steel toilet. The right to a solicitor is widely misunderstood: even the Law Society’s leaflet which you are handed at the station says misleadingly ‘You have the right to see a solicitor’. What you have a right to do is contact a solicitor, who will see you when the police decide to question you, and not before (unless sie thinks you are in danger of being beaten up, refused medical treatment or suchlike).
In the first place, until the solicitor knows exactly what the police intend to question you about,sie cannot give you useful advice. In the second place, until you know that, you might tell hir about something illegal which turns out to be unconnected with your arrest: which would put hir in a difficult position both ethically and legally.
Solicitors are not paid to give you moral support while waiting, but it can be hard to remember that when the walls are closing in.The logic of this appeared when I finally saw my solicitor and his list of police questions, because until then I had been at a loss to know what I was suspected of. I knew I had been arrested for suggesting on my website that visitors might be allowed to rape my utterly consenting and wholly free slavegirl, and that my son was being examined for signs of abuse, but such shreds of moonshine hardly seemed to add up to the sinister conspiracy the police were apparently hunting through the virtual depths of my computer.
The list enlightened me: half of it focussed on the casual mention on my site that I am a Pagan, with such leading questions as How does your religion affect the things you do in the dungeon? (A: Not at all.) I had thought that the Satanic Ritual Abuse Myth had been buried at Cleveland. They should have put a stake through its heart.
I didn’t need the solicitor to tell methat it is far harder to defend yourself against an imaginary charge than a real one. After a little discussion he advised me to keep silent. Politicians and the police have been glad to let the misleading claim be put about that the right to silence has been abolished. What has changed, he explained,is that if you mention something for the first time at your trial, the judge may suggest to the jury that you made it up since you were questioned. The solution is to give the things you want to say in a confidential, dated statement to your solicitor, who can produce it if necessary in court to show that your position hasn’t changed. I said ‘No comment’ to everything the police asked, from ‘Do you beat your slaves?’ to ‘What is your son’s name?’, and was released on bail ten minutes later.
It seems fairly certain that the police have nothing to make a case,but as I said at the start, they don’t have to; they can do me plenty of harm without having to prove a thing. They have my computer and all my discs, with all the addresses and correspondence to run my business and keep in touch with friends, all the backups for my website, and two novels I have been writing for years, and with a little creative form-filling they can hold onto it indefinitely even if they never charge me. All I have is the satisfaction of knowing that I didn’t give them an easy victim and a sensational court case to get everyone promoted. But when you’re up against a system this big and hostile, sometimes that’s the best victory you can get.
Anthony Hilbert
