[left to right: Mary Tinsley, Kath Holden of the London Bisexual Women’s Group, and Sue George author of Women and Bisexuality – amended for web edition]

I recently attended a Bi conference [London Friend] where ‘Bisexuality and Feminism’ was subject for discussion – but most of us bi women said we weren’t feminists. Feminism seemed to conjure up an image of old-fashioned lesbian radical orthodoxy inappropriate for post-modern Britain. I found it quite pathetic listening to our inability to distinguish radical feminism from lesbianism. Do we really not know lesbians are many other things across middle-class liberal, post-modern feminists, as well as none of these things at all? Is it so inconceivable that Radical Feminists could have been Bisexual? Radical Feminists viewed patriarchy as the primary determinant for female oppression. That is it. I hope in assuming Radical Feminists were man-hating lesbians, we ourselves are not falling into stereotype gender/sex/political traps.

It’s as if bisexual practices are presumed to equate with equality among the sexes. Somebody said equal pay among men and women had now been achieved. Where did that load of tripe come from? Does the economic position of women have any relevance to bi woman? Logically, economic equalities are likely in our laissez faire society. The emergence of £3.00 and £3.60 as a minimum wage is hardly something to boast about. Does it matter to us that a single parent mother trying to make ends meet is a depressed bisexual too? Does it matter if a bi wife feels disempowered in asking her husband for safer sex, never mind anything else? What if she gets STIs through his secret bisexuality? Or if she believes bisexuality is a middle-class self-indulgent sport? She could feel guilty, ashamed, less of a woman, promiscuous or irresponsible for being bisexual. Are these not feminist issues?

Post modernism has done little more than deceive our minds. Founding ‘fathers’ in Foucault, Derrida and Barthes have said brilliant things about ‘universal narratives’ as functional controls in mythical notions of truth. I am grateful for their deconstructions but we should question why these white middle-class French men seemingly wanted to destroy the structures in which their very elitism exists. Odd they should use an esoteric language, given their disdain for dominant forms of control. Anthropologist Feminists suggested white men, in fearing a loss of world dominance, emphasised a theory that effectively said, “If we can’t have it, you can’t either.”

In a way it worked ‘cos Blacks and Feminists groups fragmented, telling each other, “Ah, we are mere social constructions without real legitimacy… we all have different experiences… goodbye.” Of course there’s something right and liberating in that, yet these constructions are experienced as real if the economy, legal system and social/political structures remain in place to maintain a particular shared objective/subjective experience. As Merl Storr pointed out, it used to be called oppression. The London Bisexual Women’s Group and recent admissions to institutional racism testify to the contradictions in post modernism. The attitudes of Blair, Clinton and Milosevic are products of the same inconsistencies.

I am a Black Feminist though naturally I can’t conclude all Black Feminists are like me, Bisexual, or that all Bisexuals are Feminist. Still, my bisexuality informs my feminism and my feminism, my bisexuality. For me they are interconnected insofar as there cannot be equality of one without the other. Thankfully there are other things to consider in class, culture, religion and absolutely anything else. All of these things add to a greater understanding of myself and others, both narrowly and in a broader context. Quite frankly, given the global and local patterns of oppression through race, gender and sexuality, why wouldn’t I be a Black Bisexual Feminist?

Thus, whilst it’s clear that our male society hierarchically oppresses both men and women for the benefit of a few privileged men, surely that does not justify an apathetic interest in feminism on the part of bi women. Society ‘thinks’ through men; a particular class yes; a particular colour yes; even a particular school okay, and but for the incredibly mentally blind, these things must not be ignored by us as bi women.

Before you rush to conclude that feminism has out-lived its day, ask of yourself, “when did you, your mother, sister or in a woman’s life generally, alter in her most privately confined of domestic ties?” Anybody have a date?

Likkle more still.

Marlene Ellis

 

On women-only space

Some people might not understand why I felt the need to defend women-only space. I wrote the talk partly as a response to some individuals from the mixed Bi group. They had complained of existence of a women-only group in competition to them and told me that our group took women away from their group and artificially distorted the numbers making their group male dominated (which became self perpetuating because women didnÕt want to attend male dominated space).

They had also accused our group of deliberately keeping ourselves separate from the rest of the Bi community and not wanting to be involved in mixed events. I wanted to make it clear that mixed events are actively promoted at our group as a matter of policy and that at least some regular members of our group do actively want to be part of the whole community.

Personally I believe in a women-only space and also made it clear at the talk that I would also be happy if there was men-only space – the more bi groups the better – it can only increase our community. We are not in direct competition with the Friday group because we provide something different but even so – competition is healthy! I also believe in building links between the groups and thought that this talk was very useful for that purpose.

Mary Tinsley