Bisexuality – confessions of bisexual men and women
Jason Douglas (Published by Senate, an imprint of Random House, 1967
Reprinted 1997, ISBN 1 85958 503 5)
I happened upon this little gem in the gender studies section of my local bookshop. Inevitably it was the only bi title that has made it this far.
The alarm bells started with the first sentence: “All men and women are, to a certain extent, bisexual”. It turns out that Jason Douglas originally wrote the book back in 1967 – the year that sex between men was decriminalised in England and Wales. With the renewed interest in bisexuality, Random House Publishing obviously saw the need for a reprint. Unfortunately, they didn’t spot the need for a major edit. No biographical details are given for Douglas, but he is clearly writing from a psychiatric background of the time.
For the princely sum of £2.99, you too can be treated to 191 pages of old time prejudice. I thought Richard Littlejohn was a bigot – get this: “There are, in other words, men and women who, despite the ability to lead a normal heterosexual life, also indulge in homosexual and lesbian practices… They are simply bisexuals who enjoy the favours of men and women virtually indiscriminately… The roots of bisexuality, its causes, are often evidence of genuine psychological disturbance.”
Despite the crass comments, the writing shows clear signs of sympathy toward these poor wretches. It’s interesting to see how things have changed. With the context of a foreword and footnotes this could be a worthwhile historical record. However, there is no attempt to update it. Random House appear to have heard the ring of cash registers, whipped out a dusty volume, slapped on a cool cover photo and sat back to wait for the money to roll in.
book cover Whilst the portrayal of bisexual orientation is a poor excuse for publishing, the failure to amend information regarding health risks is outrageous. Alan H explains “I could tell at once he liked it, so late that night, I went over to him and I put my penis up him. He said it hurt a bit, but he liked it. I think he was queer because he really liked it. It felt great to me too. Tighter that a girl and absolutely no danger.”
The chapters on “The Nymphomaniac” and “The Satyr” (we differ from others only in that we’re too sex-crazed to control our unnatural urges) go on in much the same vein.
What really bothers me about this kind of crap is that this was the only obviously bi book in the shop. This is the kind of nonsense an anxious teenager is faced with amidst the shelf of queer books in a shop full of straight propaganda.
Steve Pointer
Dimensions of Bisexuality: an exploratory study using focus groups of male and female bisexuals
Journal of Sexual and Marital Therapy 13.2 (1998): 145-157
Dinesh Bhugra and Padma De Silva
Just passed on to BCN, this paper, based on detailed interviews with members of the London Bisexual Group, makes an interesting gauge for contemporary ways of understanding bisexuality within healthcare/counselling professions.
In many ways it is a positive sign of how bisexuality is becoming recognised and validated. Throughout, the writers affirm that bisexuality is legitimate and authentic, that bisexuals face hostility that limits our freedom and happiness, that bisexuals are re-thinking conventional constructions of sexual identity, and that a strong base of community groups and public affirmation is important in generating self-esteem.
Importantly, they also remind us that bisexuals are not necessarily any more free than anyone else from assumptions about gender. Questioned about ‘feminine’ attributes in male partners and ‘masculine’ attributes in female partners, participants generally felt that “an exaggeration of these traits may lead to unattractiveness” (150). But despite this essentially affirmative tone, I’d take issue with three assumptions that seem to inform it, and which suggest problems in the nature of the growing acceptance of bisexuality.
Firstly, it repeats that old cliche that bisexual desire is more free than other forms of desire: “because bisexuals are unconstrained by gender boundaries, they have a larger field of eligible partners from which to choose” (152). So entrenched is this belief that the authors state it even when they have already pointed out that bisexuals impose thoroughly traditional limits on their own desires. More seriously, though, this assumption that bisexuality moves beyond gender ignores the range of other criteria that come into play: no mention, for instance, of whether these seven white bisexuals between 23 and 33 use race or age as a way of deciding who they find attractive.
As bisexuality becomes more visible, we need to make sure that we don’t forget that sexuality rests on an attachment to very particular sets of attributes – sometimes in ways that are simply sexy, and sometimes in ways that are ruthlessly exclusionary, and require more interrogation.
Secondly, although there is a general recognition of the pressure on bisexuals to stay closeted, this remains within an essentially liberal notion: “social misunderstandings and ignorance are surely among the factors contributing to the suppression of bisexual identities” (155). Fair enough – but aren’t there roots to this hostility? Isn’t it more than just unfortunate misunderstanding? I would suggest that this ‘suppression’ has a great deal more to do with patriarchal organisations of gender, the segregation of different types of work under capitalism, the notion of white culture as restrained and asexual, and the failure to make any final break with a Christian tradition founded on hostility towards the human body. By treating ‘ignorance’ as a self-contained phenomenon, rather than one with determining roots in profound social inequalities, the paper encourages us to assume that the best way forward is a spot of awareness raising by well-intentioned professionals, rather than any more radical social upheaval.
Finally, as always with the work of professional social scientists, there is no recognition of the role that activist and community-based initiatives have had in shaping the analysis that the writers produce. They reference fellow professionals as the source of the fact that bisexuality is stigmatised and for pointing out the particular difficulties that bisexuals face: but surely it is the courageous voices of bisexual activists that have been at the forefront in raising these issues? Even if some of these quoted professionals are bisexual – Fritz Klein being the most obvious case here – I’d still like to see the social sciences recognise that they are learning from our work, our publications, and our own analysis of the situation, rather than letting it look as if it is they and their colleagues who are responsible for providing an analysis that we didn’t already have for ourselves.
Jo Eadie
