A response to Steve Pointer’s article in the last issue of Bi Community News.

Steve Pointer’s article on strategy exposes the fundamental problem with the bi community as a campaigning force. It is very small and incredibly diverse, and in many ways, ineffectual.

Size: London is probably the biggest gay city in Europe. The London Bi Group, Women’s Group and SMBis have a combined membership of, say, 3-400?, allowing for duplication. My local Quaker Meeting or trade union branch has more members than the LBG. A third of the LBG’s membership leave every year and the average bod stays on the committee less than two years. Or look at BCN’s subscription level.

Diversity equals diffusion: the community contains sex radicals who want to overthrow all existing definitions and assumptions, and moderate liberals who want the nastier laws tidied up a bit. Some bis hanker after acceptance by straight society, others want to be in the lesbian and gay community, others still dream of a bisexual future where we can do our own thing. Women-orientated women have only a limited interest in men looking for women.

Such divisions are not absent from the wider community. However, lesbian and gay radicals and less-radicals can unite medium term around fighting particular laws and discrimination, whatever their long term aims. Eighty percent of OutRage’s agenda is straight off the Stonewall manifesto. There are no specifically anti-bisexual laws and the only specific anti-bisexual discrimination I am aware of is by gays and lesbians (and it is nasty but not life-threatening or job threatening). We are discriminated against by straights because of broad-brush homophobia. Often, this means that all we end up being is a little echo ‘us too’ to broader campaigns for equality.

The community is a therapeutic organ. It allows people to come to terms with themselves – that minority of bis who for a while feel that they fit in. If it has a political role stronger than a few campaigning individuals and local groups, it is by bearing witness. Confident bisexuals in their own trade unions, campaigns, local queer communities can make the point that the prevailing analysis conflicts with our experience. With a relatively small and invisible community behind them, such confident individuals will be rare and sometimes easy to silence.

This is a limited and in some ways very defeatist analysis, which throws most of its hope on the future. As society becomes more tolerant, pressure to conform will lessen, and the bisexual space will get larger. (I am staggered by how young people are coming out now, and in some cases, how easily and confidently.) I don’t see how a handful of activists can do more than keep publications and groups going, run a few conferences, and recruit their own successors before they burn out.

 

Steve C