The Kinsey scale has now ingrained itself into popular consciousness to the extent that most people within the LGB community (and many outside it) know, or think they know, what is meant when someone is described as a ‘Kinsey 2’ or ‘Kinsey 6’. And bisexuals seem to have an especial fondness for it – after all, most of us would be able to place ourselves somewhere between 1 and 5, so theoretically we can lay claim to the vast expanse in the middle of the scale.
However, to many of its detractors this is exactly what is wrong with the Kinsey scale. If bisexuality can lay claim to such a large proportion of the sexual territory, doesn’t this lead down the slippery slope towards ‘everyone’s bisexual really’ – however much those Kinsey 1s and 5s may protest that they do not define themselves as bisexual? By this reckoning the only ‘pure’ straights are the Kinsey 0s and the only ‘pure’ gays and lesbians the Kinsey 6s, an absurd state of affairs which in no way reflects the reality of most people’s lives and experience. Alternatively, there is the danger of defining the ‘pure’ bisexual as bang in the middle of the scale, the perfect Kinsey 3, while all the others are just straights or gays in denial. In other words, the Kinsey scale can be used to prove exactly what you want it to prove.
The American psychiatrist Fritz Klein (author of the suspiciously titled The Bisexual Option) became frustrated with the limitations of Kinsey and derived the Klein Sexual Orientation Grid, which is vastly more complex and has seven variables – attraction, behaviour, fantasies, emotional preference, social preference, gay/straight lifestyle and self-identification. The advantage of this is that it can take account of such individuals as the political lesbian, the religious celibate and the gay-identified bisexual. The disadvantage is that it is far more tedious to explain that you are a 6, 3, 1, 7, 4, 2 and 5 on the Klein Sexual Orientation Grid than it is to say ‘I’m a Kinsey 3’.
Granted, there is a certain amount of psychological satisfaction in being able to describe yourself in such convenient shorthand as that afforded by Kinsey, but much the same could be said of astrology, the Myers-Briggs personality type indicator or the various classifications dreamed up by market researchers and management theorists. How much importance you attach to your label depends on your opinion of the system that produced it: knowing you are a ‘Kinsey 2’ may be more or less important to you than knowing you are an Aquarius.
Maybe we need to start asking ourselves why we are so attached to Kinsey. Does the concept of sexuality as a continuum really serve us well as bisexuals? Or does it simply reinforce the view that we are just watered-down lesbians and gays, lost in the middle of the sexual wilderness? Come to that, does it do lesbians, gays and even straights a disservice by placing the ‘real’ straights and gays at opposing poles and making them feel their sexual identity is somehow inauthentic if they ‘slip’ just a little? A one-night stand, a bout of teenage sexual experimentation and your perfect Kinsey rating is shot to pieces, leaving you adrift in the wilderness with the bisexuals snapping at your heels. Maybe in the final analysis, the continuum model is simply not a very accurate or useful way to look at sexuality.
Claire Parry
