A main topic of discussion at this year’s Bicon was the question of whether some more formal structures were needed in the bi community – mainly centred on the issue of Bicon itself and the financial liability faced by its organisers.
Krayg has written this report for the benefit of BCN readers who weren’t there, and those who were there but felt that the options (and hence conclusions) weren’t explained well enough.
The Wider Bi Community
The plenary discussions highlighted that there was no need for any sort of organisation to encompass wider bi-issues. Some people had previously suggested some form of educational charity to inform about bisexuality, promote safer sex/sexual health, organise bi events, support local groups etc. The feeling is that these vital jobs can be done by independent groups so as to reduce the risk of a ‘Bi Peter Tatchell’ ‘figurehead’ type of person developing. ‘We are such a wonderfully diverse community, no one group can represent us’ was the underlying sentiment.
Bicon and Financial Liability
There’s nothing inherently wrong with the way Bicon is organised, but little improvements are being made – for example the setting up of BAG (Bicon Adivsory Group) and the permanent contact points (BM Box, and email).
The main improvement that was seen to be possible and/or needed was to reduce the personal financial risk to the Bicon organisers. The turnover of a Bicon is now over £10,000, and a more widely targetted event could be a lot bigger. With these figures, a low attendance or a disaster (e.g. the accidental calling out of fire engines!) could easily leave the event showing a £1,000 or £2,000 loss. Since the event has been organised simply by an informal group of people, this loss would legally fall to them to repay – they are liable. Reducing this liability is essential to enabling more people to come forward and offer to organise in the future.
Also, the nature of the business is that payments have to be made well before the conference, but most years’ organisers have started from scratch money-wise.
Three options for solutions were proposed:
1) incorporation, forming a limited company;
2) insurance;
3) a ‘Friends of Bicon’ scheme.
Option 2 will be investigated by the organisers and/or BAG, and Option 3 had itself several different ideas within it:
a) network of people promising early that they would attend and paying some or all of their fee in advance;
b) people who would pledge to underwrite part of any Bicon loss, should this occur;
c) a group of people donating or loaning money to create a ‘revolving loan fund’, which could be lent to the organisers of each Bicon to form working capital with which to put down deposits on venues etc.
These were considered at a couple of workshops, and comments from plenary were also noted, and the following conclusions:
a) unnecessary since each year’s organisers could themselves set up early booking and payment arrangements, particularly if the date and venue were known by the previous year’s Bicon, and deposits could be taken there (as may happen now with the three-year-in-advance planning!).
b it was felt that the generosity of the bi community had already been demostrated with, for example, the collection at the end of Birmingham’s Bicon, so it was felt that trust and positive thinking were more appropriate than setting up such a scheme.
c) perhaps less satisfactorily discussed and explained; doubts were raised as to how to do it, and it was pointed out that people could offer loans to the organisers anyway.
Option 1, ‘Bicon Ltd’, was the most discussed. The advantage would be limited liability (see box); the disadvantages would be a certain amount of administrative burden and a possible tax liability. The former mainly means we need another kind person from the bi community to be the company secretary (a job best done by someone for a few years to keep some continuity), and the latter might be solved by creative design of the company or ‘creative accounting’. But basically, a limited company has to file accounts, and if Bicon made a profit then it would have to pay about a quarter of that in tax.
It was felt that Bicon should, if possible, be given the option of not being a company, and this should be possible. The organisers of Bicon 1998 are keen on incorporating, so it was agreed that there is no reason they shouldn’t. Then if Bicon 1999 wish to continue with the company structure they can; if not it can be folded or made dormant for a year.
Other ‘Structures’
The plenaries and workshops gave rise to a few other valuable suggestions:
- more support for local groups;
- more events, some regional, maybe another national event six months from Bicon, maybe non-residential;
‘National Bi-Visibility Day’ – a co-ordinated set of local events or actions throughout the land!
Krayg
Krayg is a member of Catalyst Collective, who provide help with legal structures to small workers’ and housing co-operatives. For further information, contact him through BCN.
Incorporation
As a general guide, most voluntary organisations incorporate when they begin to employ paid staff, lease or own property, or expose themselves to debt (borrow money). As an unincorporated body, the members of the group are all personally liable for the actions of the group. After incorporation, as ‘a limited something’, the organisation has its own legal identity in law – a ‘legal person’ includes incorporated bodies as well as flesh and blood people. Thus it can own monies and property, borrow money and sue/be sued in its own right.
There are two types of limited body, ‘Companies’, and ‘Industrial and Provident Societies’. Many co-op and community businesses are the latter. Companies themselves have three main classes: PLCs (Public Limited Companies), Companies Limited by Shares, and Companies Limited by Guarantee.
The first named have publicly available shares and suit very large businesses; the ordinary share companies issue shares to their directors and investors, and suit trading businesses. The last named is the structure favoured by voluntary organisations since they don’t generally exist primarily to ‘be in business’.
The members of the company all ‘guarantee’ a certain sum (usually £1 or £10) as their ‘limited liability’ towards the debts of the company.
Limited Liability
The people who run the organisation and are responsible to make the decsions are called ‘directors’. For Bicon these would be the main organisers, and thus are the people who stand to benefit from the limited status.
However, they are not immune to liability: if they can be shown to have been fraudulent or negligent then they lose their limited liability. For example, if they booked a ridiculously large and expensive venue, knowing that they couldn’t attract sufficient attendees to break even, then they would be seen as negligent.
