Ruth Holliday stands up for BBC2’s twenty-something soap.

The rather jaundiced review of This Life in BCN18 has prompted me to write in on a number of counts. First, and most obviously, to defend my TV highlight of the week, and second, to point out some related issues drawing on some arguments from media studies which are relevant to the way we, as bisexuals, watch TV.

Whilst it is inevitably a part of reviewing to be ‘critical’, some programmes take more ‘critique’ than others; bad (‘lowbrow’) television taking more than good (‘highbrow’) TV. Recently, this tradition has come in for some stick. Bad TV is the staple of most viewers’ diets (especially mine), so according to the critics we must be a bit stupid to watch it. This has been especially true of soaps. Male critics watch a couple of episodes, review them as pure trash, and condemn their (mostly female) viewers as a few bricks short of a load. Early feminist writers on soaps also took this line, seeing women as being conned by the capitalist and masculinist media into confining energy to romantic imaginations rather than channelling it into the women’s movement! However, if you start with the proposition that women are not, after all, stupid, then some alternative explanation has to be found for the pleasure of soaps. This lies in collection of possibilities and nuances which build up over the viewer’s experience. The soap viewer is rewarded for loyalty, years of experience opening her up to dim and distant characters, plots and possibilities which could re-emerge at any time to disrupt storylines. The occasional viewer or critic will obviously miss these possibilities.

This is what I really love about This Life; not the plot development, or central storylines, but the subtleties of the relationships between the characters. This is the pleasure of viewing, and pleasure is why we all watch things we know we shouldn’t.

Still, maybe we are not supposed to consider this. After all, these are not Bi issues and surely the job of BCN is to find Bis on TV and assess their representation – positive or negative. But what exactly is a positive representation and is this what we really want to see? Ferdy, in This Life is probably far from positive. He is confused and uncomfortable in queer and straight spaces. But more importantly he makes those around him uncomfortable. Witness Miles’ behaviour when Ferdy joins him and Egg down the pub. Miles spends the night scorning Ferdy’s expressed attraction to ‘babes’ and his enjoyment of playing pool (obviously a ‘man’s game’), and keeping him at a distance, presumably in case he pounces on him in public and gives him a quick one over the pool table.

Warren’s behaviour is even more delightful to watch – trying to get Ferdy to acknowledge what Warren believes he really is – gay – and to feel at home with it, passing him his therapist’s card as a parting gesture against accusations of pushing (therapy) from Anna. Aren’t these the real joys of the programme: his unsettling influence on the other characters, not whether or not he is a Bi for us all to look up to.

This brings me to my final point. The Lesbian and Gay programme Out was born out of the ‘positive representation’ debate. Each week it featured a brave and true lesbian or gay man living a principled and difficult lifestyle – remaining steadfast in the face of oppression. A role model for viewers to look up to. But after initial success viewing figures dropped to about one million. In its final year of broadcast Out was brought forward and The Golden Girls was shown directly afterwards. Viewers rose again to around three million. Out became the warm up for The Golden Girls.

Probably the best explanation for this has to do with pleasure. Is there really a pleasure in watching people that leave us feeling we have something to live up to, or are we better off watching Ferdy with all his faults and laughing sympathetically along with him, knowing that we’ve all been there? Or is the pleasure in the way we watch the programme after all? It is in interpretation that we have the most to offer ourselves. Out is a serious programme; The Golden Girls is most definitely not. This is the difference between lesbian and gay programmes and queer viewing – between seriousness and fun.

Looking around for positive representations of Bis on TV is a depressing task. Any representation is rare and if truly positive representations were shown, would they give us what we really want from our TV sets – pleasure? And whose idea of positive would they represent? Surely we are freer to embrace Bi or queer readings of TV. Thus, watching This Life, what self-respecting Bi woman doesn’t, momentarily at least, have the hots for Anna, or long to give Millie an intimate massage when she gets in from the office, or give Miles the fuck he’ll never forget before waking at 6 and slipping quietly out to never see him again – we all have our favourites. But queer readings are an important consideration – it’s why Phil, Grant and Joe are EastEnders gay heart-throbs and not Simon and Tony; why Ellen has been a Dyke favourite long before her recent coming out. Here is the ‘fun’ of viewing and not the politics.

To a certain extent TV, in fact, often encourages queer viewpoints. In any programme the camera places the viewer in the position of many characters, showing first one person’s perspective and then another’s. The camera has no consideration of who is male or female in its audience and thus, in the course of most programmes we are placed as male relating to female and female relating to male, sometimes even as male/male female/female. Perhaps, despite its greatest attempts, TV positions us all as Bi after all.

Ruth Holliday