Valentine’s Day is a traditionally a day for lovers. But do we need a day for celebrating friendship? Is there a boundary between the two?
Bisexuals, particularly politically active ones, feel the need to differentiate their relationships from the heterosexual norm. When a bi person asks themselves: `What is the difference between bisexuals and the rest of the sexual orientations?’ they usually come up with the idea that bisexuals have different types of relationships. Many will tell you that the boundaries around friendships and relationships are different from hetero/homo relationships. It is the permeability of these boundaries which give bi identity its special flavour.
There are bisexuals who want to blur the distinction between friendship and sexual relationships as much as possible. The argument goes: what is the difference between a friendship and a sexual relationship? The usual answer is that a sexual relationship involves sex, dummy. Not so fast, the reply comes, what is exactly is sex? Oh come on, we all know that one – the answer is it involves physical touching and that it can involve orgasm. Let’s leave touching aside, because you can do that with friends as well as lovers.
OK, let’s take a look at orgasm. What exactly is orgasm? There are differences in the way different genders experience orgasm. Men and women experience them differently; men tend to associate ejaculation with orgasm. Once you take out the fact that most men experience orgasm as ejaculation (they can be very different things) then the closest you can come to a definition is orgasm involves a release of physical and emotional energy. But you do that with your friends, don’t you? There are some flaws in the argument, yet sex is an elusive thing which, the more you look at it, the more elusive it becomes. Those convenient definitions disappear and you are left with culturally defined definitions.
The most usual ones involve sleeping together, getting naked and for men, ejaculation. But many bisexuals sleep with their friends. And not only bisexuals. What about all those straight people on camping holidays? People get naked for pleasure with friends as well; what about all those rugby players? I think you can get the picture.
Once the decision is taken to explore exactly what the boundaries around different relationships are, the problems can start. And those problems can come from others as well as from your own confusion.
Judie Brendel and Joan Scanlon, writing in Barking Back, a feminist magazine, categorise the problems like this; `The ubiquitous, irrelevant and insulting question: “Have you got a lover?”‘ The answers, it is assumed, bear on: your identity; your sexual availability; your accessibility as a friend; the way to treat your lover; the need to include your lover in social arrangement and accord to them the right to impose themselves without invitation; an expectation of your limited ability to function independently of `your lover’.
They are particularly keen to put the knife into the concept of a `lover’ having special privileges not normally given to your friends.
`Imagine welcoming or even tolerating the presence of an uninvited stranger joining you on holiday, coming to dinner, or staying overnight in your home, if she wasn’t taken on faith simply by virtue of her sexual connection (however short-lived) with an established friend who you have no wish to offend. This attitude is reserved almost exclusively for lovers.’ They have a point. On some occasions it would be nice to have the choice of refusal. But there is the excitement of getting to know someone new, seeing your friend in a new light.
They go on to attack all the other assumptions which are usually associated with straight relationships
`All the stuff that goes with being in love… even the sense of amazed good fortune at being on the same planet as someone you respect and care about intensely – all of these things are true in different ways of our friendships so why is the term love not good enough?’
`What about the excitement and enthusiasm which an new friendship can inspire? What about the intense feelings which evolve but do not diminish in a relationship?’
Friendships, they seem to be saying, are undervalued and can be as important as a lover.
Stuart Miller in Men and Friendship, writing on male friendship from a straight perspective says: `Most men, particularly if they think about it, if they let themselves feel their personal truth about it, will admit they are disappointed in their friendships with other men. Men may have wives, they may even have women friends, but their relationships with other men, which could be a true echo of their manhood, are generally characterised by thinness, insincerity, and even chronic wariness.’
His exploration and researches into male friendship concluded that friendship between men is necessary and need as much work as sexual relationships.
I have found that one on the liberating aspects of bi identity is a freedom to be friends with other men in a way heterosexual men would have to fight hard to do. I sometime sleep with my male friends, without feeling pressured to have sex or with deep fears around homosexuality.
H.J.
