About twenty people attended the workshop on ‘Bisexuals, Lesbian And Gay Men Working Together In Unions’, at BiCon ’96. It was a shame that there were only about five UNISON members there.
The workshop took the form of an introduction and then questions from the floor. Murray Forgie and Lisa Thirlby from the UNISON Lesbian And Gay Group attended to put their opinion of how they see queers working together in UNISON.
Bis Excluded From Lesbian And Gay Group
After an introduction about how UNISON worked, and particularly how the self-organised groups worked, questions were invited from the floor. As everyone was interested in the exclusion of bisexuals from the UNISON lesbian and gay group, Murray took some time to explain how it had come about.
He said that the idea was that bisexuals were essentially different from lesbian and gay men and therefore needed to organise separately. He was at pains to affirm that bisexuals are discriminated against and that UNISON as a whole opposed discrimination on any grounds.
Both he and Lisa also cleared up some points about UNISON’s funding for Pride. Funding for Pride was not threatened by the name change and would continue. Good to hear this. Both Lisa and Murray were keen to find out how they could work together with bisexuals.
The focus of the questioning was then on what the essential differences between lesbians and gays and bis were when organising in the workplace. This was an area which generated the most heated questions. The audience were clear that from their perspective the differences between sexualities didn’t warrant a separate group. The UNISON officials were clear that it did, but weren’t good at coming up with compelling reasons.
The argument seemed to be that they were different labels and therefore should organise separately. Murray did say that he felt comfortable in discussing problems to do with homophobia when in the company of lesbian and gay men but might feel uncomfortable with bisexuals around. There was a bureaucratic justification that the Lesbian And Gay Group is part of the UNISON rule book and so can’t be changed.
There were some pointed questions about how lesbians came to be organising with gay men. A UNISON member pointed out that she is a lesbian and said that her bi partner suffered the same homophobia as she did at work. She wondered why bis were thus excluded from the UNISON Lesbian And Gay Group. Both the UNISON officials were very surprised at her remarks. I had the impression that they both had got it into their heads that lesbians and gays didn’t have relationships with bis.
Both Murray and Lisa emphasised the fact that bisexuals had the right to self-organise. They also made many points about the Lesbian And Gay Group coming from a long process of struggle and that ‘it wasn’t handed to them on a plate’.
Speaking to the officials afterwards, they both said their impression was that people didn’t listen to what they had to say. The people who attended the workshop said that their impression was that the UNISON officials didn’t listen to what they had to say. Interesting comments, but I disagree. Both sides did listen to each other but perhaps no-one has changed their opinions.
Kevin Saunders
