Dominic Davies is the editor of Pink Therapy – a new book on lesbian, gay and bisexual issues in counselling, published by the Open University Press. What can bisexuals learn from it ?
BCN: Given that doctors now seem happy to prescribe Prozac on request, why do we still need counsellors?
I like that question! I can think of a variety of answers to it. From the cynical – because counsellors still need to earn a living – to the more serious: that some people prefer to work through their problems rather than just anaesthetise themselves to their pain.
BCN: Since the psychiatric profession has done so much to have us institutionalised, pathologised and indeed still has practitioners who believe they can cure us, do you think lesbian, gay and bisexual people ought to be careful about going into counselling?
Absolutely! I think we need to be very careful. In fact, one group that I’m involved with (The Association for Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Psychologies) has produced a leaflet on finding a gay affirmative therapist, which suggests questions people might like to use in interviewing a potential therapist to try and suss out their queer-friendliness.
There are many of us who have been on the receiving end of very damaging therapists. I constantly hear stories of poor practice from members of our communities who have experienced the sometimes well-meaning and naive questions from ignorant therapists – and I am being kind when I put it like that. This was the reason behind writing Pink Therapy. I wanted to try to find a way of sparing clients the task of educating their counsellors about their lives and mental well-being.
I would encourage anyone contemplating therapy to get hold of the ALGBP leaflet and use it as a starting point to finding a therapist. There are not many ‘right’ answers a therapist can give to the questions we suggest, but their manner of answering the questions, their tone and level of comfort at being asked such questions, will all give information to the potential consumer to help their decision.
BCN: Do you think it’s important to find a therapist who shares your sexuality – and if not, are bisexuals likely to be more at ease with a lesbian/gay counsellor or with a straight one?
I think what is most important here is: ” how do I feel about sharing my experiences with this person? Do I sense them judging me? Do I feel they are open to hearing about my life and genuinely interested in me? Do I sense they are getting off on the details of my sex life? Are they trustworthy, affirming, and sensitive?” Do you see what I’m getting at here? I am not sure the sexuality of the therapist is all that important; it’s the quality of the therapist. Personally, I’d rather see an experienced straight therapist who is queer-friendly than an inexperienced gay one.
I also think it’s about what we feel we need at the time. Some of us know we want to talk to someone who has had direct experience of coming out; of homophobia; or of managing dual identities etc. Others of us want acceptance of our ‘queerness’ preferably from someone who we feel has no vested interest in affirming it.
BCN: A lot of us feel concerned that while a straight counsellor might think bisexuality is just an adolescent phase that we grow out of, a lesbian or gay counsellor is more likely to see us as going through a ‘confused’ phase en route to deciding that we’re really lesbian or gay. Do you think that’s a reasonable worry, and what can we do about it?
Either way I think it’s deeply insulting to bi-people to assume they don’t know who they are, and to want to slot them into some neat categories. Bisexual identities are a whole lot more complex than that, as indeed are straight and gay ones!
I think we have every reason to be worried about being made to fit someone else’s paradigm. One of the problems I see in my work as a trainer of therapists is that very little is actually taught on counsellor training programme about human sexuality, and diversity. Oh, they might acknowledge that some people are lesbian/gay, but they don’t usually see bisexuality as a separate identity, which isn’t an expression of gayness, but an acknowledgement of attraction to both men and women as a genuinely third sexual identity. I think the bi-community itself has only recently been making these distinctions clearly, and it’s a development I’ve seen coming out of bisexual activism and theorising about bi-practice.
BCN: Given that your book looks at the needs of lesbian, gay men and bisexuals in therapy, did you find bisexuals had any particularly different needs from lesbians and gay men?
I think the needs for all three groups are remarkably similar to that of any group – to be accepted, to have someone try to understand, to have someone interested enough to try and help the person make sense of their life and predicament.
What I did find interesting was how most of the writing around gay affirmative therapy has ignored bisexual people. Sure bisexuals have seen gay therapists, but they have been treated as if they were gay, and not respected as being bisexual.
Very little research has been done around bisexual psychology, or checking out how applicable gay theoretical models are to bisexuals. This was my original interest in coming along to Bicon, as I wanted to see how developmental models for coming out which were developed for gay men and lesbians adapt for bisexuals. How far does the bisexual experience of coming out follow a similar pattern to lesbians and gay men ? I found some of the models needed adjustment as a result and British bisexuals helped move the theories forward here!
This lack of theory around bisexual psychology means that whilst we have tried to include bisexuals in our case examples and made use of theory where we can, it’s likely that more work needs to be done on this area. I’d be very interested to have feedback on the book and whether you feel we’ve got it right or what other things we need to address. We are likely to have to reprint sometime soon as copies are selling so well, and we can revise the text.
The leaflet ‘Finding a Gay Affirmative Therapist’ is available from ALGBP (UK) P O Box 7534 London NW1 0ZA. If you have feedback to offer on bisexual perspectives in counselling, you can send correspondence to: Dominic Davies, Senior Lecturer in Counselling, The Nottingham Trent University, Burton St, Nottingham NG1 4BU.
