Brian is gay?
‘I have always identified as gay – my friends, surroundings, fantasies and relationships are all with other men. I have had sex with a number of women, but these encounters have not been serious – simply a release of a bit of fun, when I wasn’t with a man. It’s the gay relationships which have been important and have had meaning for me.
‘I only fantasise about other men. I believe that our sexuality is defined by our fantasies and our encounters. Too much importance can be attached to occasional sexual contact.
I therefore believe that I am gay as are a great many people who identify as bisexual. “Bisexual” is often a position adopted by people who have not yet come to terms with their sexuality.’
As told to Steve Pointer
People should be able to label themselves
I want to see a far greater acceptance of bisexuality and the fluidity of sexual preference. That’s why it’s a huge own goal to tell people who they are and how they should identify. For me that builds barriers and does nothing to bring them down.
The crucial factor is people’s understanding and acceptance of bi lifestyles. Without this everyone could call themselves bi and we’d still be no better off.
A case in point is Tom Robinson, the man who wrote and performed ‘Glad to be Gay’ in the 70s. He is now in a relationship with a woman and they have a child, though Tom still identifies as gay.
This might sound obtuse – his life history indicates bisexuality. His explanation is that he feels exactly as he did before the relationship; why then should he change the word by which he is labelled? It is a term with which he feels comfortable and which has meaning for him.
Now, I’ll admit I’m a Tom Robinson fan, but I believe I’m justified in defending his outlook. He doesn’t hide his opposite-gender relationship – referring to it in the press and in his songs – and he’s suffered rejection by many gays as a result.
He has always stood up for the right for people to have sex with who they want. Surely this openness is the important issue – not the word with which people identify themselves.
Steve Pointer
Sam is a lesbian?
‘I define as a lesbian. I grew up assuming I was straight, discovered bisexuality, and then, a few years ago, realised I was a dyke.
‘I still do “erotic” things with men but there are some things which I’ll never do.
‘I don’t have anything to do with their genitals. I’ve always disliked men’s genitals and loved women’s.
‘I’m comfortable with bis and spend a lot of time in bi space, but I object to people trying to force the label on me.
‘I’m a lesbian. While I can get “erotic stimulation” (getting turned on, orgasms etc) with either gender, I only “erotic fulfilment” with women – a fulfilment which is both sensual and spiritual.
‘The social consequences are also a reason for avoiding the bi label. I often socialise in bi-phobic lesbian spaces, but if I was really bi, I would admit it and face the consequences.
‘What I do with men is a tiny thing tacked on to a far corner of my sexuality compared to this big thing (my lesbianism). It’s a kink in my lesbianism and I don’t think it’s worth risking my friends for.
‘I want to ask the bisexual community a question. Why do you feel the need to conscript people?
‘We all have the right to choose our own sexual identity label. If you don’t understand someone’s label you should ask them – they usually have a good reason for it.’
As told to Caramel Quin
If words and meanings can be swapped…
Words have got a lot of power. They signify things. Language is one of the most central and important things we share. What does language mean? It means common understanding, common concepts.
And sometimes these concepts are not what we want to hear. I don’t like being called fat. It’s usually as an insult, and when it is, I don’t like it. Doesn’t stop me from being fat though. I’m happy being fat, but if I weren’t would I still be fat? Yes.
If words and meanings can be swapped around, then I’m a woman and I’m black. How offensive is that? So I can do sexual things with members of both sexes and I’m gay. Yeah, right. I might be mostly gay, nearly all gay, but not-at-all bi gay? Nope.
So why do people do this? Why do people pretend words don’t have meanings. Because they don’t want to be what they are. It’s not cool to be bi. You’re not as oppressed if you’re bi. Whatever. It doesn’t alter the truth – it’s closets for bisexuals.
The love that dare not speak its name? ‘Gay’ men and ‘lesbians’ who daren’t admit that they do things with the opposite sex. Because if they do, they’re out on their ear.
We’re the small community caught between two huge communities – straight and gay – and until people start standing up and admitting to themselves, and others, what they are, it’ll stay that way.
Simon Munk
