The Economist (16th Jan) has come out for same-gender unions. The same edition that argues “Let them wed” also carries a survey of gay and lesbian activism world-wide.

The arguments are two-fold. Firstly, the state should not discrimate without reason. Arguments of tradition and religion are briskly dismissed. Inter-racial marriage, or the bride refusing to swear to “obey” were once unthinkable too. Secondly, marriage is promoted as being not just good for gays but good for society as a whole. The aim is ’emotional and economic stability’, no less.

This is the point at which I start to bridle. I’m in favour of people having the choice, and in favour of those people who want to making that sort of commitment. Some people are called to that degree of commitment, and if two people are going to raise a child together, there’s something to be said for a legal relationship between them. However, I’m not keen on it becoming normative.

To look at the Economist’s arguments:

  • ‘Marriage is a great social stabiliser of men’ – (it makes them buy insurance and get mortgages, rather than go clubbing every night).
  • ‘Single people are economically vulnerable and more likely to fall into the hands of the welfare state’ – (married gays might look after each other rather than rely on welfare).
  • ‘Married people are happier and healthier’ – (saves NHS costs).
  • ‘The real choice is between homosexual marriage and homosexual alienation’ – (gays might be more docile if they spent more time on DIY).

So being single, or in a relationship that is likely to be short-lived, is really a form of disability. Single people are, by definition, second rate, and in their emotional-life, failures. Or am I being hyper-sensitive here ?

I can see many gays, lesbians, and bis of my acquaintance mouthing ‘aping straight society’, ‘rats joining the sinking ship’, ‘propping up a failing institution’. Even Andrew Sullivan (writer of Virtually Normal), a passionate supporter of gay marriage, admits that it might create a new class of ‘cultural insiders’ – a way of co-opting a conformist minority, and making them a stick with which to beat the rest of us.

Yet some of the arguments against same-gender marriage are facile. Arguably it might further change straight marriage: after all, the traditional gender roles are going to be further undermined by same-gender partners living on the same street. The state can’t force someone to play ‘wifey’.

And the knock-on effects for all non-straight people would be enormous. Discrimination in employment, housing and education would be immediately open to challenge. (In particular, because the Sex Discrimination Act would require everyone to give the same gender couple of the same rights as a mixed gender couple.) That does go some way towards helping the single non-straight person, if not being the whole of the solution.

Perhaps this is the real issue. Do we believe that people can love each other, and become married in each others eyes, whatever the law says ?

Steve C