They say that if you market a range of size-based condoms you don’t mark them “small, medium and large”, but large, extra-large, and mammoth. An industry then, clearly untouched by feminism. Our own Steve P investigates.
When I first proposed writing an article about condoms being the wrong size I didn’t realise the grief I would be causing myself. Comments from friends seem to have fallen into two distinct groups. Firstly, the cynics. Comments included “you old size queen”, “oh for God’s sake stop bragging”, and “look, I can get a condom over my head and inflate it. If you can find someone who they’re not big enough for, give me his phone number”.
I would have given up on the article if it wasn’t for the slightly less frequent, but nonethless persistent, comments of a second group. There did appear to be a problem with condoms not fitting a sizeable (pardon the pun) minority. And there is a serious point at issue. If condoms are difficult to put on, split, or come off before the wearer does, safer sex is at risk. Constantly worrying that a condom will fail is hardly conducive to enjoyable, relaxed sex. Repeated failures could result in people involved giving up on protected sex altogether.
Some initial research turned up an article in the British Medical Journal written by Stuart Tovey and Chris Bonell, which lent weight to my theory. Entitled “Condoms:a wider range needed”, the article reported on a survey involving 281 men who visited a GUM clinic in South London.
Just over one fifth of the men who responded to the questionnaire said that condoms were too tight. The instances of reported failure amongst this group were considerably more common:
76% of men who found condoms too tight reported condoms coming off, as against 51% who did not find them too tight.
68% of those complaining that condoms were tight had experienced them splitting, compared with 26% who did not find them tight. (BMJ Vol.307 , 16/10/93, p.987).
It seems obvious why condoms that are tight split, but why do they tend to come off ? Chris Bonnell, now working for the HIV Project, explained. The reason for both failures appears to be difficulties in getting the condom on properly. If it cannot be rolled fully down the shaft, it allows the ring at the base to enter the partner and so pull the condom off. A condom will tend to split, not because it is too small when on a cock, but because it was damaged while rolling it on or is not on properly. Chris’s answer explained my friend’s comment about being able to blow a condom up over his head. It’s not the width when the condom is unrolled that counts, but the width before, and while, you roll it on (you try stretching a rolled condom out wide enough to fit over your head – it’s a very different story).
So, there appears to be a problem; but are all condoms really the same size? I think most of us follow that good advice given since the 80s and go for a British Kitemarked condom. After all, they must be the best ….
British Standard BS 3704:1989 dictates the design criteria for most of the condoms sold in the UK. Key requirements are sizes: and only two are specified. The first is modelled on the British standard penis – the condom must have a flat width of 52mm, give or take 2mm. The second is generally referred to as a “snugger” (ie smaller) size. Any condom made to a different size could not get a Kitemark. Most condoms available in the UK are therefore of only two sizes: “standard”, and “snugger”. Ths adds another dimension to the lack of choice offered by most high street stores, health authorities and charitable trusts.
Before you decide it’s Femidom or nothing, it’s worth knowing there are alternatives available. Non-kitemarked condoms may come in other sizes. In particular, US brands tend to be made to a larger standard, based on WHO statistics. There are also some super-large condoms, with names like Mamba and XXL, if you think you are in that league. Specialist shops such as The Condom Shop in Leeds and Condomania in London can help. However, without a kitemark we don’t know their quality. The answer in the long-term would appear to be a rethink by the British Standards Institute and the London manufacturers. In the short-term? I guess the answer is: shop around and find one that fits and suits you and your partner(s); use plenty of water-based lube, avoiding condoms lubricated with Nonoxynol-9 if that irritates you; and check that the condom is in date. That, or tie a knot in it.
