All Folked Up
A review of Queer as Folk
Ten thirty pm, my other half and I waiting expectantly in front of the TV for the start of C4’s Queer as Folk with only hype and the advertising to go on in making us decide to watch.
This programme was a first for queer media in that it had a highly visible mainstream media campaign. I applaud Channel 4 in putting their money where their mouth is and going for the high profile publicity angle.
Because of the hype around the programme I had expected something that would be controversial but what I didn’t expect was three major characters who appeared from the first episode to have few positive redeeming features. Whilst not arguing for ‘kid glove’ treatment in the media for queer subjects I do feel that at least some effort could have been made to balance the selfishness of the main protagonists. I have no problem with the showing of selfishness as it is part of human nature but it is when this selfishness is shown as being all there is I start to have a problem.
Personally I felt that there were a lot of negative stereotypes about queer people in the programme and did worry about the effect on any non-queer people watching, or those people unsure of their sexuality. It could have reinforced pejorative views of queer people rather than helping to alleviate them.
I was bothered by the underage sex in the first episode, both from a personal perspective and from a political one. It did seem to be bringing out the old stereotypes of ‘Gay = paedophile/nonce’ that you hear spoken in saloon bars across the country. Especially as the age of consent issue is coming up before parliament again. Although to temper this I have heard that in later episodes Stuart does refuse to sleep with Nathan because of his age.
This was probably quite an accurate portrayal of some parts of the young gay scene, what worried me was the possibility that everyone of minority sexuality would be tarred with the same brush.
A first episode of any drama has a difficult responsibility as it has to set the scene for the rest of the series and keep people watching. Despite strong reservations about the programme and it’s portrayal of queer characters, I am not going to condemn it out of hand but will watch other episodes to see how it develops.
In a way it is good that issues of monogamy, gay marriage, age of consent etc were raised and it may open debates on these subjects.
One of my favourite verbal moments in the episode was when Nathan asked an older gay guy what clubs were the best and he replied ‘if you want selfish queens try that club, if you want total arseholes then any club along here will do.’ This summed up my major worry about the programme in that there were a lot of ‘total arseholes’ in it, although it is possibly an accurate portrayal of part of the queer scene it is not by any stretch of the imagination a portrayal of all of it.
After all even Grant Mitchell in EastEnders, possibly the most unsympathetic character in the series, occasionally gets to show a positive side to the character. Would it be asking too much for the writer of Queer as Folk to do the same with his characters?
Mark Taylor
