Having an unambiguous physical gender does not always mean that you feel you fit in to society’s expectations…

I’m a woman. The breasts and vagina tend to give it away, even if my voice often confuses people. Do I have a gender? Not really. Gender implies that I identify as having a ‘female mind’, mentally different from people who identify as male. Which I don’t think I am. I have, however, always been treated as a woman, so if this hasn’t made me see myself as ‘female’, how has it affected me?

Some argue that how you are treated has to define your identity – e.g. Germaine Greer claims that a post-op TS woman isn’t a ‘real’ woman as she hasn’t been treated as one from birth. I disagree, as this assumes you have to conform to how you are treated (do you have to be a permanent Methodist if you were raised as one? Could you ever really convert to another religion and believe it?).

There are certainly many differences in how men and women are treated and behave in various situations – I doubt anyone would dispute that. Equally, many of these are changing slowly. Most restaurant staff now hover until one person at a table takes the bill, or else places it in the middle. People are getting used to the idea of women doctors, barristers, bus drivers etc., and the more it happens, the more it will have to be accepted as normal. However, assumptions on what ‘women do’ exist, and it seems that the more you look, the more you find, even among my generation where at least the idea that women will work has filtered through. Older generations seem just to be more open about how they think women should behave, such as my first boss who claimed he ‘couldn’t understand discrimination against women, they look so pretty in the workplace’.

If a male/female couple are going anywhere, their friends and the man himself will assume he is driving, especially if it’s a long journey. And the reaction of many men to a woman joining in a conversation about cars, computers, or football would be more appropriate if they’d been talking about how it feels to have their penis fondled – shock, acute discomfort, and a definite feeling that this is a topic that only men can discuss. Have all these kinds of opinions on what is ‘right’ for a woman to do affected how I see myself? I think not. I’ve found that if I come out with my own opinions, men will accept this as ‘normal’ and are quite happy to include you in the conversation, ‘bloke subject’ or not.

How does the typical woman act? From most of the ones surrounding me throughout my life, it seems that to be female you have to be obsessed by diet and your looks, talk endlessly about your relationships or your children or both, and obviously be heterosexual – presumably the reason most of the women I get on with aren’t heterosexual is because they don’t conform in general. Seeing as I never fit a ‘female’ mentality in the first place – not being able to get excited about makeup aged 13, not understanding the huge imperative to have a boyfriend aged 16 – it’s possible that I’ve responded in a positive feedback manner and become less and less ‘typically’ female over time. I’ve given up trying to act ‘feminine’ because I’m no good at it, and the more ways I find a woman expected to behave, the more I see how they just don’t fit who I am. I think being a woman has made me more aware of how different sexes are treated and how they tend to act themselves, but hasn’t been a defining factor in how I see myself or in making me think differently to that section of the population who have penises and a slightly different pattern of hormones. I’m just human, but quite happy to have the vagina, thank you.

HT