The question of gender is no more clearly exposed than in the area of intersex. Poppy browses this hidden domain, and bookmarks the bisexual links.

This is what threw the issue of gender into the most mind-blowingly stark relief for me: meeting a mother who, in the delivery room, couldn’t get an answer to whether her baby was a boy or a girl – they couldn’t tell. A raft of doctors decided whether the baby should grow up a girl or a boy; and followed up that decision with hormone treatment and surgery!

What is gender when you are intersexed? About one in 12,000 children are born with ambiguous sex organs. Their hormones have gone haywire in the womb. Though the chromosomes (XX for girls, XY for boys) are supposed to direct sexual development, if the hormones don’t get to do their job, bang goes your theory and the bipolarity of man versus woman is suddenly blurred.

So, for example, in AIS (androgen insensitivity syndrome) an XY foetus doesn’t have the units in the cells that allow it to respond to androgen (the ‘male’ hormone) and the genitals don’t masculinise: they go for the default development, which is female. While in CAH (congenital adrenal hyperplasia) the adrenal gland produces too much androgen and in XX babies the genitals partially masculinise.

What do the psychologists find? That XX babies with CAH who are reared as girls (there’s surgery involved and continuous medical care) usually have strong female identities, though they tend to be more interested in boyish things such as outdoor sports. They also have a higher than average chance of being bisexual, or lacking interest in sex.

I met two teenage sisters with CAH: both are happy and well-adjusted, both huge Arsenal fans (possibly not so well-adjusted then… Sub-Ed). One was not sexually active, the other identified as gay. But not all intersexed people do so well.

A.J. Sinclair (is it Jo or Joe?) has had a much less happy experience. Her (his?) intersexuality only became apparent in the early teens. ‘I was subjected to the efforts of a series of well-meaning ‘experts’ to help me,’ s/he writes on an intersex web page. ‘When I persisted in refusing to accept the female gender assignment that would have made my medical management easier for my doctors, it was decided that I should be assisted in adopting a male gender identity.’ It was going to be one or the other!

J. wasn’t interested. S/he relates hilarious tales of the doctors trying to persuade her (it?) to become used to owning a penis. Initially that involved wearing a pair of socks in a jock strap – they worked their way out and fell to the ground through the trouser leg. ‘I didn’t understand what all the fuss was about,’ s/he confesses.

Raven Kaldera had a different problem. Raised a girl, at about 12, ‘my hips spread, my voice began to break. My breasts grew and so did my facial hair,’ she writes. She relates how the suffering extended over years and included an unwanted baby and various hormone treatments. ‘I spent nine months living in a little cabin on the banks of the Quabbin wildlife sanctuary going crazy. My body was withdrawing from all the medication and I had psychotic mood swings, terrible depression, and very scary uterine hemorrhages.’

All this landed Raven in hospital where someone finally gave her testosterone. ‘I felt as if the sun had come up,’ writes Raven. The depression lifted, the bleeding stopped and her energy returned. But when she wanted more Raven was told she couldn’t have any. ‘Regular doses of testosterone of that magnitude are indicated only for transsexuals,’ said the doctor.

So Raven set about persuading the doctors she was a transsexual. ‘I didn’t exactly feel male. For that matter, I didn’t exactly feel female either,’ writes Raven. ‘I’m still not exactly sure how one feels male or female.’ But he did a good job persuading the doctors. ‘I now find myself at the intersection of the growing transgender community and the budding intersex community,’ he says. ‘I am committed to both groups, like I am committed to the queer community because I am bisexual, and to the world of men and women because I am a little of both.’

J., meanwhile, far from being a bit of both is neither and has remained asexual, but that has had its own pitfalls. Love has proved treacherous. ‘There have been people who have acknowledged that my feelings [of love] are valid and that… whatever form of sharing and communication springs from that love is also valid,’ s/he writes. However, ‘if the expression isn’t fairly similar to the most popular expressions of intimacy through sexuality then the love must not be real…’ J. laments that this rejection of the love s/he offered ‘is an even more fundamental attack on my integrity than the obsession with genitals.’

The question of gender leaves most intersexuals silent. The bipolarity of gender oppresses them cruelly, and they cannot win. ‘Intersexuals who are subjected to neonatal surgery undergo that early physical trauma and resulting lifelong trauma on many levels,’ states the web page on intersexuality. While ‘intersexuals who miss early surgery often grow up alone and confused… and often abused.’

That abuse can be serious sexual abuse; institutional abuse in the form of dehumanising tests and constant medical interference in the most intimate parts of life; and the social and emotional abuse that comes from the grim insistence in our society of the centrality of gender to human status and the limitation of the choice to just two.

Poppy

 

For more information see: www.qis.net/~triea