She/he, ship/shore; seafaring and the rainbow seas. Historian of the rainbow seas Dr Jo Stanley looks at an aspect of bisexual life for a cargo ship officer in the 1970s.
Michelle Clark is a transitioning person who spent their first twelve working years on cargo ships heading for ports from Mexico to Japan. The 1970s were a time when they thought of themselves as a bisexual man. And now you can read the autobiography about that time: From Ship to Shore and a Whole Lot More.
Here was a working-class person from the Midlands, starting to become an officer. Someone proud of their Starsky and Hutch-style Vauxhall, ‘like its owner, fast and impressive.’ Someone who was hoping to marry a woman. And then…
What does this memoir show about one person’s bisexuality in that exceptional faraway space – the ship on distant seas? Not the glitzy world of camp stewards whose main interest was in having a laugh a minute, a new dress for the ship’s ball, and a few shags a night with someone who looked like a Tom of Finland exhibit.
COVERT V CAMP
Instead the book reveals the covert world of British deck officers who’d lose their job if their love of men – however part-time – became visible to authorities. In the hotel side of shipping life in the late 20th century, on some ships gay man made a party where ‘Everything’s queer once you’ve left that pier,’ as the saying went. But, in the seats of power, closeting was crucial.
Seafaring was one of the occupations – along with theatre work – that sometimes allowed some men to shape the space to be fluid – at a time when homosexuality was still illegal. In studying gay life on ships in both the merchant and royal navies I often come across stories of men who ‘were happily homosexual’ at sea but seemingly equally happily married to women ashore.
Apparently this wasn’t just a case of men having contingent sex with whomever or whatever was available on board at the time of need. (Historically even ship’s goats had been roped in as partners.) These were serious relationships: taken up again at the start of each voyage; then put on hold when the ship docked and shore leave began; and then sometimes restarted if fate had parked them together on their next ship, or the next. The major part of a merchant seafarers’ life was spent in close proximity with their shipmates, not spouses.
Some of this is touched on in Hello Sailor: Gay Life on the Ocean Wave, the book and exhibition I was involved in shaping. Evidence remains in the Sailing Proud Archive at Liverpool’s Maritime Records Centre, which contains oral histories. Because my quest at the time was for gay, not bi, seafarers there is not as much evidence as I’d like about bisexuality.
So it’s very interesting that a new book, just out in summer 2021, reveals a new angle on bisexuality at sea. In From Ship to Shore and a Whole Lot More, Michelle Clarke tells a story of transitioning to female, after identifying as a bisexual male when at sea.
A former First Mate, Michelle now describes herself as ‘an attractive and inspirational woman of legal standing who waits for the surgery that will finally give her the body her mind has always known is hers.’
BISEXUALITY
The book is written in the third person, about Michael, then about Michelle. So there is a missing ‘I.’ Out of respect I follow Michelle’s usage of pronouns, although it feels more right to say ‘they’.
BCN readers should not expect the book to focus on bisexuality. It refers to it in passing. But readers will be interested in Michelle’s references to living bisexually in a way that roughly follows the pattern outlined above: gay ashore, hetero at home.
In 1972 Michael first went away to sea, with the Reardon Smith Line. True to the stereotype of a sailor having a girl in every port he met a young woman during a month’s unloading in Saint John, New Brunswick. (Turnarounds in port were much longer than the fleeting hours spent in ports these days. This meant that off-duty seafarers had long enough periods to permit all sorts of relationships to develop.)
The book implies that the romance might have continued. But ‘Michael was sexually attracted to men too.’ Home on leave, he and his friend BP went on a camping holiday, where his feelings towards BP grew. Although Michael wanted to get physical with him, he knew it wouldn’t happen as BP had found a girlfriend. Michael’s desire didn’t appear to be a revelation to hm. Both the male BP and the unnamed Canadian woman faded out of the picture. The next reference to sexuality occurs when, on the Amparo in Japan, ‘Michael decided to go to a gay bar in Kobe he’d found in the Spartacus Gay Guide … that he was secretly carrying round with him. He remembers well how kind and friendly the locals were and what a great time he had. It was a shame he couldn’t share his experience with his shipmates though, as being gay was still a crime for seafarers.’
That paragraph shows the loneliness of that period in history. In 1967 homosexuality on land had been partly decrimalised in the Sexual Offences Act. But people in the armed forces and on merchant ships were punishable by dismissal, a ruined career, and shame. If the sex was non-consensual and with a minor (a person under 21 until 1970s, then under 18) then homosexuality was an punishable by a stretch in jail.
GAY SHIPMATES AT LAST
Michael was climbing the career ladder, taking his first officer exams, and enjoying the relief of sailing with an out gay chief steward on the Josefa. This appears to be his first time sailing with colleagues who were neither homophobic nor anti-sissy.
Cargo ships tended to be less gay-friendly than passenger ships, and so freight companies were only attractive to gay men who preferred all-male communities. P&O was at the top of the camp men’s list of favourite operators. The giant enterprise was far from progressive, but campery was convenient. Managers loved enjoyed the impeccable, witty and reliable customer service offered by the many camp stewards on glamorous long-distance ships.
On the Josefa, whose cargoes included Belgian automatic rifles and ammo destined for the Mexican Navy, Mike found that ‘being quite camp, SS was easy to get on with … he and Michael had lots in common.’
As for PH, the captain’s steward, ‘Michael simply fell in love with him. When …rumour had it that they sometimes spent time together in Michael’s cabin it didn’t take long before one engineer “nonchalantly” walked past or had a peek through his porthole to see if he could catch them in there.’ Shipmates didn’t necessarily grass up gay colleagues. However a bit of scandalous gossip was always welcome to enliven tedious trips.
At the same time, when on land Michael was also enjoying two consecutive relationships with women. The long one with JW ended because he wanted to get engaged and marry – she didn’t. Then he switched to AT, who demanded a lot of sex ‘because she was set on getting pregnant.’ He wasn’t.
The author remarks ‘Neither girl knew that Michael was bisexual. Not that he’d kept it from; just that it had never come up in conversation… the reason behind Michael’s bisexuality would eventually reveal that he would never be able to have children.’
This cliffhanging statement is a reference to Michael’s later discovery of a physical problem.
MY GUY’S THE CAP’N
But before we reach that point there’s what appears to be a very satisfying interlude when Michael has a sexual relationship with the captain of the MV Welsh City, a bulk carrier. The captain ‘had heard the rumours going round the fleet Michael was gay, but he also knew he’d had girlfriends.’ And at slack moments the boss invited Michael to his cabin for a beer.
Soon, ‘With no intention of lying to him, Michael openly admitted to being bisexual … [And] despite him having a wife and two boys back home [the captain then] admitted he was bi-curious … and attracted to Michael.’ They acted on their interest: the captain came up onto the bridge after midnight and joined Michael on watch.
‘Things progressed quickly, and soon Michael was spending all his “sleeping hours” from 6pm to midnight’ in the captain’s bunk with him. ‘As neither of them could afford to get caught, it was a very difficult – albeit thrilling – situation and a secret they managed to keep until the ship arrived in Baltimore, USA’ where a new captain took over.
(The switch was as scheduled, not because the company had discovered the officers’ criminal activities. And there’s no reference to whether the closeness continued.)
The next part of the story is of an incident that led to Michael being found to have Klinefelter Syndrome. The author describes this as having ‘an extra female chromosome … Michael was born half male, half female, which also known as “intersex”. ‘
From then on the book is an account leading up to transitioning, which was done initially in the company of his then-wife Sue, the divorced partner of one of Michael’s shipmates.
At the time of writing Michelle was living as a woman and beginning a new relationship. The gender of his new partner is not mentioned, which is par for the course in a reticent memoir.
Meanwhile, homosexuality at sea and in the armed forces was decriminalised in 2000. In the Royal Navy, which has become vociferously inclusive, sexual orientation and gender are said to no longer be issues.
In the much more varied world of passenger ships personnel experience different sorts of permissive attitudes. Any continuing homophobia and bi-phobia – and indeed misogyny – is usually expressed by shipmates from non-permissive cultures: Rumanians and Ukrainians can be especially hostile.
In a 24:7 goldfish bowl the challenges remain: how to live life freely despite close peer surveillance. And in seafaring in general there’s the issue everyone faces: balancing life ashore, including raising kids, with long months afloat when sometimes there’s no internet.
As for any human being, the challenge is how to intimately connect with the people you love, whatever your current places on the gender and sex spectrums.
Finding out more
See my interview with Michelle in Nautilus International’s Telegraph, 21 March 2021. https://tinyurl.com/Michelle-Nautilus.
From Ship to Shore and a Whole Lot More is published by Amazon (2021) and sold there: https://tinyurl.com/From-Ship-to, ISBN 978-1-914195-27-3. Price £14.50 for paperback.
The book, Hello Sailor: Gay Life on the Ocean Wave, by Paul Baker and Jo Stanley (2003) is published by Routledge and available at https://tinyurl.com/Hello-S-Amazon for £28.53. I SBN 9780582772144.
The exhibition, Hello Sailor: Gay Life on the Ocean Wave, was at Merseyside Maritime Museum. https://tinyurl.com/MMM-exhibition. You can take a virtual tour of the Hello Sailor exhibition as it was in 2008 at https://tinyurl.com/Homotopia-Hello.
