What the papers say…
The Sun lives up to its reputation for sheer nastiness. We have a column by Anne Atkins (vicar’s wife and Radio 4 busybody), along with a leader article and an inside page report. No doubting where The Sun stands: it’s against it. We have it all; the leader article goes for the ‘gay sex is unnatural’ angle, Anne Atkins goes for the discredited ‘gay men are all paedophiles’ angle and the inside page report digs out Nicholas Winterton to make his usual bigoted remarks. The sheer quantity of lies and misinformation in The Sun’s coverage of the issue is not matched by any other newspaper – even The Daily Telegraph is mild by comparison.
The Daily Telegraph goes for the more subtle approach. They run a ‘knocking’ article by a gay man who, surprise surprise, wants to keep the age of consent to 18. Simon Blow, clearly a man not at ease with his sexuality, gives the usual stuff: queer people will never ‘adjust’ to their ‘outsider’ status; men are natural hunters, so male-to-male sex is always predatory and promiscuous. He then goes on to say it doesn’t matter anyway because guys look the same at 16 as they do at 18.
The Times wheels out Roger Scruton to put forward that old chestnut – boys mature more slowly than girls therefore they will be at more risk from predators than girls. He then goes on to his favourite subject, the ‘failure of liberal society’. His rant takes some careful reading, mostly because he is very good at winding up potential liberals without actually saying what he wants (other than a return to the status quo?). He blames the whole liberal idea of making sex easy and therefore weakening life-long commitment between people. He blames the whole sexual liberation movement for neglecting children, taking them out of marriage. Interesting, but it is the usual right wing trick – blame the individual for something that is right across society. Read any social history and it becomes very clear that children have been systematically disempowered for a long time, and the whole commodification of sex by the free marketeers who have used sex as a pacifying device is rather missed out as well.
The Daily Mail just does what the Telegraph does. It wheels out a gay right angle (bent on the outside, straight on the inside) to tell us (yawn) that the potential change in the law is driven by the ‘aggressive’ gay lobby and will do untold damage to the young. Daniel Farson complains of the ‘politically correct’ actions of the few gay activists who have somehow conned the whole government into changing its mind. Please, Danny boy, lay off the electric shock therapy for a while, it’s giving you delusions.
The Daily Mirror goes for the ‘guys can have sex at 16 but can’t smoke a cigarette afterwards’ angle. They are also the only tabloid to quote queer activists – Peter Tatchell and Chris Morris. Chris Morris, a young gay whose action led to the potential change in the law, writes his piece. Unfortunately, it is accompanied by an article by Dr John Campion of the Men’s Movement. This is not the Men’s Movement where guys try to get in touch with their masculine side, it is the old fashioned gay-bashing, hetero-affirming movement.
The Daily Express just puts Peter Hitchens in front of the word processor and connects him to the nearest lightning conductor. Obviously the bolt struck, because he manages to churn out the usual stuff. He focuses much on the change to 18 for cigarettes at the same time as the change to 16 for sex. He seems to start OK but can’t quite stop himself from going on and on about gay sex not quite being as proper as hetero sex.
The Independent actually tries to think it all through. It has an interesting leader article on sex and smoking and why the ages of ‘consent’ should be different for them both. It is the only paper to try and look at the facts behind the equalisation of the age of consent. It is the only paper to attack the fetishization of sex by the free market as a selling tool. It does get some things wrong – it thinks that sexual orientation is just genetically determined – but on the whole it is a breath of fresh air.
The Guardian can’t quite make up its mind whether it likes queer people or not. No leader article, just a feature article by Jonathan Freedland who looks at the whole confusion about the which ages people are allowed to do the things usually considered as adult.
Readers of BiWatch might have noticed something in the all the above comment. Not one remark about bisexuality. It was all gay this and gay that. Even lesbians were largely excluded from the articles. Where were we in all of this? This issue is something which affects us very much as a community, yet we were completely invisible to the mainstream press. This is an issue which we need to continue fighting for. Anyone who wonders why bi activists get so worked up about the issue of visibility should try monitoring the press whenever there is a queer issue. The systematic attempts to render all except ‘acceptable’ queer voices invisible is an issue which should get us all going.
Kevin Saunders
The next issue of BCN will have a feature on the age of consent question.
