The Houses of Parliament debated conversion therapy this evening.
So-called conversion so-called therapy promises to change a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity. It is used to supposedly turn gay people straight, trans people cis, and bi people either gay or straight dependent on which identity is more strongly pressed for by other influences in their life.
The debate was not actual legislation to ban the discredited practice though. It was a Westminster Hall debate, where interested MPs discuss an issue but legislation cannot arise. It was prompted by a petition on the parliament.uk website which garnered around a quarter of a million signatures.
Many MPs – nearly a tenth of the House – put in bids to speak and the debate ran out of time without them all getting to contribute, so we missed contributions planned from MPs like Oxford West & Abingdon’s pansexual rep Layla Moran. Neither Labour bi MP Cat Smith nor fellow bi Brexiteer Tory Daniel Kaczynski MP appear to have thrown their hat into the ring to speak.
Some cited stories from constituents about having undergone therapy, though they were all about being gay or trans.
Elliot Coburn MP opening the debate explained how it came to be held.
“It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Gray. The petition is entitled, “Make LGBT conversion therapy illegal in the UK”. The prayer of the petition states that
“I would like the Government to:
• make running conversion therapy in the UK a criminal offence
• forcing people to attend said conversion therapies a criminal offence
• sending people abroad in order to try to convert them a criminal offence
• protect individuals from conversion therapy
“Despite all major counselling and psychotherapy bodies in the UK, including the NHS, condemning LGBT conversion therapy, it is still legal and LGBT individuals in the UK are still exposed to this psychological and emotional abuse to this day. The very thought of this sickens me, and I would like to see it stopped one day.”
“When the petition closed, it had 256,392 signatures, including 487 from my own constituency of Carshalton and Wallington.”
He went on to outline his opposition to the practice and make starkly plain how awful it can be:
“These so-called therapies can manifest in many forms, from pseudo-psychological treatments and aversion therapies to practices that are religiously based, such as purification or fasting. At the most extreme, there has been evidence that this practice can also involve physical and sexual violence, including so-called corrective rape.”
Warrington North MP Charlotte Nichols spoke about being bisexual for what we think is her first time in 15 months as an MP, observing: “All our major faith groups support a ban, as was reiterated at the interfaith conference held remotely in London in December 2020. As a religious Jew and a bi woman, I have been heartened by contributions from hon. Members in the debate who hold their faith close to their heart but know that there should be no dichotomy to reconcile between religious freedom and protecting the safety, wellbeing and dignity of the LGBT community.”
SNP member John Nicolson explained how these issues had affected him: “I do not know why I am gay. I do not know why I have green eyes or curly hair, but I do know that no one made me gay; I was born gay. When I was younger, to borrow from Alfred Kinsey, I would have taken a magic pill to make myself straight, but I now know that that was not because I hated being gay, but because I did not want to be the victim of prejudice.”
Crispin Blunt (Reigate) took part over video call due to the pandemic. Having outlined as a benefit of the proposed change that, “When victims find themselves under pressure that is improperly applied to convert them to something they are not, they will know that it is against the law and that they can call it out,” he suffered a brief loss of connectivity. He resumed: “The law gives the victims the opportunity to go to the police and, therefore, to have a weapon in their hand against the source of a conversion therapy. The state is on the side of victims’ freedom—the freedom that that individual is trying to take away from them.”
He went on to highlight the “T”: “such protection must include trans people. They are by far and away the most vulnerable group among the LGBT community. Identity around gender dysphoria is surely a much more challenging thing to meet than a minority sexuality, but all must be protected. The law must include trans people, and not only because they are the group who need it the most. In 2018, it appeared that trans people were on a trajectory to achieve their rights and protections to live their lives as they wished, supported by the Government’s comprehensive LGBT action plan, but all that now seems to have changed. Trans people are a community under siege. Organisations whose principle raison d’être is to attack and challenge the very legitimacy of trans people have come into being, and they appear to trans people to be firmly in the ascendant.”
Fellow Conservative David Mundell highlighted how many people were affected and lambasted the practice: “the national LGBT survey demonstrated, that this is going on in our country: 2% in the LGBT+ community had received such therapy and 5% had been offered it. We must treat the term “therapy” with the contempt it deserves, because we must be clear that this is not therapy; it is a pseudo-psychiatric 21st-century snake oil.”
And Cardiff Labour MP Stephen Doughty challenged the idea that people need to be free to opt in to such quackery: “I do not think that someone can give consent to this, and I was alarmed to see, I am sorry to say, in the Secretary of State’s letter attached to the debate, what I fear could be a get-out clause. It talked about “seeking spiritual support”, but we need to be aware of what that can be used to cover up.”
Mark Fletcher MP observed that “I will just say one thing to the online LBGT community who have looked today and said, “Why should there be a debate? We should just crack on and end conversion therapy.” I understand their argument, but I question that arrogance, because there is always a need to win the argument, and there is always a need to keep advancing and making sure that the things that we do here and elsewhere are led by the best arguments, and that we continue to fight that fight.”
Wrapping up for the government, equality minister Kemi Badenoch MP observed that “I take this opportunity to thank all colleagues who have spoken in today’s debate in support of ending conversion therapy. It is wonderful to see so many people united against this abhorrent practice, and I look forward to many more debates on the issue.”
After an hour and a half the meeting agreed that “That this House has considered e-petition 300976 relating to LGBT conversion therapy.”
It was great viewing but unlike Kemi Badenoch we don’t want to see many more debates on the issue. First, second and third readings of a short sharp bill would be plenty enough of them. Maybe we are arrogant in thinking we have reached a conclusion after spending a few decades thinking about it but we’d rather see the ban that was promised nearly three years ago, really.
