I’ve just watched the final part of ITV’s Bob and Rose by Russell T Davies. A mainstream TV comedy drama on (arguably) the most mainstream UK TV channel. It made me laugh and cry in all the right places. In the show a gay man and a heterosexual woman meet and fall in love with each other, hilarity and heartbreak ensuing in more or less equal amounts.
The week before the last episode Saturday’s Guardian had a Julie Burchill piece connected with it. Her take, unsurprisingly perhaps, was something like “well of course Bob doesn’t want to identify as bisexual. Who would?” She went on (over the length of the column) to identify exactly what was wrong with bisexuality and why no sane person would want to identify as bi. Wilfully missing the point and basically doing what she does best; ranting at length about whatever is on her mind that particular week, with little or no regard for anyone else’s feelings.
There was some debate on UKBI email discussion list about how best to respond, if at all. Generally the response was “she would say that” or something along those lines, with a few stronger reactions. “Isn’t that the same article her ex-girlfriend wrote about 5 years ago?’ was one notable comment.
In the show Bob repeatedly asserts his gayness when several characters insist he must be bi now. Several people assume he’s in denial. His best friend/ex/wannabeboyfriend thinks he’s ruining his life, he would think that though because he’s secretly in love/lust with Bob. Bob’s best female friend has an even more desperate, secret crush on Bob which leads her into all sorts of desperate, manipulative and ultimately destructive behaviour.
The show charts the course of three relationships as they intersect and collide. It also shows how people’s libido will generally do it’s own thing in spite of their identity. This is the sort of thing queer theorists have been discussing for years, suddenly it’s out in the mainstream.
I expect people will have read their own message into the story, one way or another, depending on their own agenda, in the same way that the characters in the show do. I suspect the story line will not feel as outre to BCN readers as many other viewers, rather more familiar territory, perhaps.
It’s the identity and behaviour quandary again. An identity label can never encompass everything about someone’s personality, desire, politics, and history, that is why we often end up with multi-labels like bisexual queer or homopunk. One label just won’t do. In Bob’s case it seems the right person for him Just happens to be a woinan, despite the fact that he happens to be gay.
There has been some interesting fallout from the show. Apparently, according to Decca Aitkenhead, writing in The Guardian on 24/10 2001, the show has been “a social catastrophe” for gay Manchester. Canal Street is now inundated with heterosexual women, wanting either the excitement and glamour of the gay scene, or possibly the company of men who are “better looking than the guys in the student union bar. And they dress better and dance better”. The fact that Bob himself feels he can’t, or won’t, really live up to the ideal seems to have escaped these women. As fast as fictional Bob tries to distance himself from the “scene” some heterosexual women seem to be flocking to it, in search of what , is not particularly clear.
In some cases the motivation seems to be to meet a “nice” man, in other cases, just a look at “the other side”. Some women seem to be going for the company of men who are not like the men they know already, whether or not that leads to some sort of relationship. There has been a variety of responses from gay men on the scene, ranging from the welcoming to the downright misogynistic.
It can perhaps seem frustrating for those of us who are out as bisexual that others find the identity so unattractive. I suppose I feel that makes it more important that we don’t claim people as part of the community, even if they are fictional.
Jo David
