Visionary thinking, representation & diversity
You’ve had an idea for a new resource for people. You’re inspired. You put hours into what you’ve started and you don’t grudge a minute of it (or a penny of the money you spend). Then other people start getting involved. Their vision doesn’t quite match yours. They say: ‘I think we should do it this way’ or even ‘I don’t like the way you’re representing us.’ Often there’s enough of a consensus that the thing can continue. But often the project becomes a battleground.
You may also be getting criticism from outside. From people who aren’t putting time, money and resources in, but still want to have their say.
So, how do you ensure useful contributions aren’t lost, or that people don’t waste energy fighting? There is no one answer, but it’s a question with relevance to us.
Representation vs Personal Vision
One crucial axis of the question is whether the initiative claims to represent the community. That implies a willingness to take on other opinions.
Some initiatives haven’t set out to represent anyone, and haven’t laid claim to unique resources. They’ve set out to fulfil their own vision, and they’re not interested in ‘designing by committee,’ or being accountable. Their idea will either work, or not. Meanwhile they’re not stopping anyone else from doing something else.
When people set out to fulfil their own vision, and it ends up corrupted by other people’s demands, they’re likely to go and play somewhere else. Then the community loses their talents. When everyone must be pleased, inspiration can go out the window.
A New Perspective vs A Clash of Vision
Even in places where there is an element of accountability, it’s not necessarily productive to criticise people’s work. Outside input can be useful to think around a problem. But input is distinct from a disagreement based on a clash of visions. Remember there are few volunteers without a view of how they’d like to see their initiative develop.
My experience is that the more satisfied someone is by the result, the more likely they are to continue putting energy into the project.
If you’re going to work in a group, you’re going to have to compromise, or do all the work yourself.
Living in a diverse world
Clearly with some projects (such as BCN) the intention is to represent the community. Then it’s appropriate to call people to account if it doesn’t look like that’s happening.
However, when the visible community is so small, there’s a tendency for people to see every initiative as designed for the whole community. That’s asking a lot. No-one expects Cosmopolitan, or The O Zone, to cater for the whole of mainstream culture. Competition and diversity are expected.
Similarly, because we’re under-represented in the rest of the world, any representation of the community is scrutinised with a paranoid eye for what it says about us. If bisexuals were in the papers every day, do you think we would care what Charlotte Raven said?
Another common theme in our community is the idea of ‘splitting people’s energies.’ This characterises new initiatives as damaging. The assumption is of scarcity.
It’s sometimes true that a new project attracts people away from old ones, but the fear of that is used to stifle many potentially wonderful initiatives. The implication is that the first thing to set up in an area ought to continue alone until it collapses.
That misses something vital. The currently existing initiative that’s about to get competition may not cater for everyone. And you may not even know that until people see something new worth popping out of the woodwork for.
Maybe that ‘rival’ project is actually your ally – strengthening the community and speaking to people you didn’t know existed. Maybe some of those people will come your way. As the diversity increases, the community expands. So you’re not competing for a static amount of people or resources.
So what?
So it’s a good idea for anyone setting up a project to think about what they’re setting out to do and for whom. If the answer is ‘I’m doing this for myself’ that implies a different relationship to criticism from ‘This is a resource for the community.’ There’s a spectrum of answers between those two.
Finally, for the people thinking: ‘If I was running that, I’d do it differently.’ Before you start angling for control, consider that what already exists may be doing just fine on its own terms and if you don’t like it, that’s a sign that your vision is of something different. Instead of one project torn by dissent there could be two, three or four that flourish.
Jennifer Moore
