In BCN 1, I wrote an open letter about discrimination in Bisexuals Action on Sexual Health (BASH) and their Vice-Chair Ian Watters replied. His reply didn’t address many of the points raised. So I’ve decided to return to these points.
BASH is an important organisation in the bi community, but it has steadfastly refused to be accountable to the community.
(Ed. We gave Ian 200 words to respond. His responses are in italics, and he wants you to know a) that he was not happy with the inequality of space and b) that these are personal responses, not a statement from BASH).
Ian and I clashed over the paid position in BASH only being available to bisexuals. Ian suggested that a non-bisexual would need training. I the competence of the candidates for the job has nothing to do with their sexual identity, and BASH have not put forward a valid argument that it does.
There is no legal ‘positive discrimination’ and, the only way for BASH to justify policy is a ‘Genuine Occupational Qualification’ (GOQ). This states that the need to be an out bisexual is inherent in the work, and no other sexual identity could do it.
Nope. Tim’s thinking of race/sex. Sexuality isn’t covered – ask Stonewall!
Ian’s example to support this was inappropriate: Positively Women – is gender exclusive as a GOQ, because of the recognised inequalities that women live with, not because of the ‘peer group’ argument that Ian put forward.
Actually for most posts PW recruits only HIV+ women for exactly those reasons. Either Tim hasn’t read the literature on peer education projects or, if he has, he hasn’t understood it. (And his idea that bisexuals don’t face inequalities is odd.)
Ian compares BASH needing to be ‘visibly bisexual’ with Bi Community News (BCN), suggesting that ‘we need a paper owned by and for bisexuals.’ BCN is organised a collective of people who may, or may not, be bi, but are prepared to produce a newsletter that reflects the concerns and news of the bi community.
Come on, look at who’s on the collective… most easily qualify as ‘famous bisexuals.’
Ian refers to my starting a bi focus group within Outright Scotland and suggests that I think a ‘group whose decisions are “owned” by bisexuals would be more attractive to other bisexuals.’ Wrong, the aim of the group is to keep attention on bi issues, but the group is open to anybody who wants to work with this view.
Ian also suggests that ‘organisations within the community, are not treated “seriously” by others in the field.’ This bears little resemblance to my experience.
The Edinburgh Bisexual Group (EBG) and phoneline are regularly consulted by the District Council and Lothian Health Board. EBG members are active on several ‘professional’ working groups and have provided training to youth workers. I think we’re being taken seriously.
Very good, but compare and contrast the way the Naz Project, or Gay Men Fighting AIDS, or other, non-bi, groups are treated.
All Quiet on the BASH Front
Si M (in Ungagged 5) wrote critically of BASH. He referred to a letter that he’d written that was not replied to. His is not the only one.
On 26th April 1995 the EBG wrote expressing the concerns I raised in my original letter to BCN. BASH didn’t reply. I raised this with Ian at BiCon ’95, and requested a written reply. I wrote a reminder on behalf of the EBG on 10th November 1995, at the same time requesting a copy of BASH’s constitution and equal opportunities policy. To date there has been no reply.
The EBG, Si M and I have all expressed concerns about the way BASH is currently working. When there has been a reply, it has come from Ian Watters and has been incomplete or dismissive.
We have a problem with the PO Box. Mail is (sometimes) delayed or returned to sender. Ring me (0181-866 3853) and I’ll give you the number of our bank, who have had precisely the same trouble in sending stuff.
I sent a postcard to Tim c/o EBG saying ‘If the reply doesn’t answer everything, ring me.’ Not a peep, until now.
BASH goes to the Accountants
The question of ‘accountability’ has arisen a number of times recently – in connection with BASH among others. Who is speaking on our behalf and with what right to do so? Are there any genuinely community-based resources? (What happens to the money when BiCons make a profit?) Do these groups represent us, or their own interests? Someone knows the answers to these questions, but who they are is difficult to find out?
A number of groups associated with the bi community are not community groups. They’re groups of people doing things their way and they are not accountable to you or any other people in the community. Does that matter? No-one seems to have a problem with the Off-Pink Collective being autonomous, but many do with other groups, such as BASH.
Several community groups, including BASH, aren’t accountable to the community. These groups want something from us, and we are in a position to attach terms to that. This is one way we can introduce accountability into what they are doing.
Argh! BASH reported and invited people along again and again and again: at BiCons, via BiFrost, via BCN. It even paid train fares and put people up. Tim would have loved the meetings (not that he ever came to one).
Anyone who responded to BASH’s appeals for involvement has been invited along, and if they came, has the same voice as anyone else. BASH has faults, but accountability is not one.
Compare that to Nottingham BiCon. It had more money than any other BiCon. How many people know that some people who ran workshops at Nottingham were paid? It wasn’t mentioned in the programme or plenaries. Who picked the ones to benefit? Who made the choice to give only to some, rather than less to everyone who did a workshop?
Tim Sallis
