Dear everyone-who-works-for-the-Edinburgh-bi-phoneline,
I wanted to thank you publicly for the help I received from one of your volunteers recently. As a ‘bisexual activist’ (for want of a better phrase) I was somewhat hesitant at phoning, in case I found myself pouring my heart out to someone I knew, but the woman I spoke to handled the situation completely brilliantly and didn’t make me feel, for one moment, that ‘people like me’ should have our lives sorted and not be in need of the phoneline. I can’t thank her enough.
I am writing this letter for Bi Community News, rather than direct to the phoneline, so that other people, maybe those who, like me, feel that they shouldn’t be using this service, can hear how helpful and sensitive an experience it was, and that, when life gets difficult or complicated, there are ways of dealing with it. The phonelines are as good a way as any I know.
An incredibly grateful bisexual person
I have been very interested to read people’s opinions about the bi community in the past few issues of BCN. Like many other people, I feel ambivalent towards it: on the one hand I am obviously part of it to some extent, yet like them, I feel there are very few people “like me” in it.
I think part of the problem for the bi community is that it consists of people brought together by just one thing – bisexuality. Yet the community’s prevailing ethos presumes any number of other things in common too – politics, style, taste in clubs etc. This doesn’t really apply to many other groups, queer or not. Lesbian and gay groups (and even some clubs to some extent) are based around specific shared politics, interests, etc., and not simply in the fact that they are lesbian and gay. This was brought home to me at a bi women’s meeting once where half the women thought we should just relax and have fun, and the other half that they could not contemplate being involved in a group they considered apolitical. So everyone ended up unhappy.
In the past this “everyone welcome” aspect of the bi scene seemed to work better, although I suspect that it always alienated more people than we liked to think. But I think this new self-criticism on the part of the bi community is entirely positive. I don’t think we can move any further forward otherwise.
All the best,
Sue George
Jo writes: So many interesting points there Sue – I wonder if another part of what we don’t share is a tradition. Whether it’s camp for gay men, or butch/femme and lesbian feminism for dykes, there are cultural traditions for those groups to bond over. I often wonder if this is why the bi community talks, writes, and runs workshops so much about non-monogamy; trying to produce a “bisexual sensibility”, as issue that’s more ours than anyone else’s ?
I’m also struck by your account of the group: why was it that when there were two sets of people who had found others who wanted the same thing, they couldn’t form two groups and both be happy ? Do we bisexuals always feel that unless we can all meet our needs together in one conference/group/newsletter we have failed ?
A recent article in Bi Community News submitted notes rom the Edinburgh Bi Group on possible conference policies. In the conclusion it was asked if it was time for mandated group to ensure accountability to the community? Of all the recommendations they discussed I was surprised that they did not suggest that conference should be followed by a written feedback report to include a financial statement. After conference, organisers are exhausted: it took Nottingham nearly a year to produce their report. Edinburgh produced one for the following conference (although they ran out before I got one). Lots of people I know are still interested in the fire engine monetary issue from the last conference. Should we be told what is done with profits? I understand that at the time of the Norwich conference it seemed reasonable that a good cause for any profits would be our national magazine, Bifrost, but what happens when things change? During Bifrost’s life we were told it was changing its printing equipment and when Bifrost finished new subscribers were told that they could not be reimbursed: is this reasonable in the light of contributions Bifrost received?
What about the current newsletter? Will it be any more accountable to us? Will future conferences tell us if they make a profit and will they tell us what they do with it? Finally Bisexual working party for the pride trust haven’t been informing people who have attended when the next meeting will be – will they be doing so?
More questions than the X Files
Jo writes: BCN offers our own account of the last six months in this issue (hope that lets us off the hook for now). Accountability looks all set to be the big bi issue for 96 in my opinion – watch this space for the start of the debate. See p1 for details of the Pride Working Group.
Dear BCN
Concerning last month’s announcement that a gay publication had banned the words “no bisexuals” from its contact ads as being offensive – am I the only bisexual to be doubtful about the value of this ?
If someone is so sad, neurotic and unhappy with their own sexuality as to want to put “no bisexuals”, then why should we waste a date on them ? After all, I reserve the right to put “no biphobic neurotics” in any ad of mine.
Steve C
Jo writes: what does anyone else think? Would you rather know in advance ? It does always get me down to see the words “no bisexuals” staring up at me – but as you say, at least we know who to avoid. Answers on a postcard …
Dear Bi People,
The newsletter is brilliant – keep up the good work! I think it’s lacking something though, don’t you? What we need is a jolly good serialised story, something that reflects the diversity of the bi community and definitely isn’t a badly written piece of wish fulfilment and a bunch of sorry media wannabes. I know, we could call it “Sellafield” (as in something you wouldn’t want to touch without donning protective clothing first). On second thoughts, maybe not …
yours in the struggle (some days more than others)
Loretta
PS Would you like me to send in some of my poems ?
Jo writes: Ah, poetry! How I wish I could accept your kind offer, Loretta. But alas, no sooner had I promised to bring our readers some poetry (see last issues’s increasingly inaccurate “Coming Next Month” box!) than the rest of the collective pointed out that part of our mandate at the last bisexual conference (which we all signed in blood) was: ON NO ACCOUNT SHOULD WE PRINT POETRY. So there you go!
